After seeing an internet streamed performance of the controversial Cadets, I see all the likes and dislikes being argued. I agree with the dislikes of singing/vocals in drum corps period and I also agree that the hornline and percussion are amazing. I was very impressed. The colorguard has the most challenging job in this whole design. They become not only colorguard, but actors/actresses as well with speaking roles. That has got to be very demanding. Learning lines and work as well as performing it all. I give them huge props.
Overall I can't say I LOVE this show but I can say that I do not hate it. They fall to pretty much 5th place in my rating. (Where they stand as of San Antonio)
I understand the controversy, but they really arent going to contend for first IMO and I think the judges are very hestitant to give them a title which is why they are not up neck in neck with Cavies and Blue Devils.
But I guess I can't really say anything since the live version is notoriously better than the flimed version.
In short thats my opinion, flame if you like.