Jump to content

ApocalypseTissue

Members
  • Posts

    353
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ApocalypseTissue

  1. I think it's hard to say for sure which brass lines are better if you're not on the field sampling each player's and each section's quality of sound, intonation, blend, articulations, etc....

    :tongue: Excellent

    Perhaps true to an extent, especially in a close call,......but if there are problems evident in the stands, then they are usually REALLY evident on the field.....conversely, if someone is absolutely stellar in the stands, that usually shows up on the field, too......

    This is why a certain corps uses derived achievement to hide from the field judge. Field judges sample, and oh certainly won't hear some things on the other side of the field.

  2. There's probably a corps that has a ton of rings under their belt, that placed for their standards a bit more disappointingly in 2008 that will come out of the gates like Mad Dogs next summer. This off season will certainly be the rattle in the cage they need.

    And Crown? That'll probably be the first corps under their target list.

  3. Technically, the new lines are very good and I agree with the level of quality spread. On the other hand, if you had heard the great g lines of the past, something is definately lacking in the bflat corps. Just a drummer speaking...
    There is absolutely something lacking.

    For this reason, what I would do... just to sit in front of 2007 Cadets for their opening hit... :thumbup::tongue::lol: That's a Bb line worthy of G bugle attitude.

  4. To be Frank, 2008 was definitely one of the more hornline-showy years.

    There was just one corps that wasn't doing up to par. Now I understand this is a formula of sorts but I think with their competition, it really stuck out this year.

    When did the Cavaliers start going to this minimal playing? In 2004, I was floored by that brass book. They were marching and playing a lot.

  5. Grow up. How I feel about the Cadets, their show designs , their talent, and their output this year and years past is well documented, I dont play games, I tell how I feel.

    So, instead of whining, did you answer the question, or are you the Cadets FMM bodyguard , defender til thy death, out to purge injustice and negativity at all costs ??? Sorry, 2008 Wasnt the Cadets year, isnt about the Cadets, they arent this years top story, and they wont be fondly remembered in 2008 for Sarah Jones and the living room. Thats life, thats drum corps.

    Geoffrey

    Okay. Well I wasn't whining.

    For my input

    Best Corps: Blue Devils

    Best Show: Phantom Regiment

  6. I'm a huge Cavalier fan, I think their designs over their years have really been impressive and sometimes stunning.

    I flipped out my cam corder of their rehearsals from this year and watched it several times.

    I just have to compare, I don't want to sound anti-cavie or anything but from my observations The Cavaliers hornline just does not play and march at the same time.

    if they're playing it usually at a stand still or on the half-time, the entire brassline rarely plays together on the move

  7. Biggest "event" on the three nights - Phantom Regiment

    Best performance Thursday night - Blue Devils

    Best performance Friday night - SCV/Cavaliers

    Best performance Saturday night - Phantom Regiment

    Best story - Pahntom Regiment

    Best idea - Blue Devils/Crown

    Best drill if nothing else mattered - Cadets

    worst use of voice - Cadets

    Best guard - Blue Devils, Crown, Phantom

    Best designed show - Phantom Regiment/Blue Devils

    Worst designed show - Cadets

    Best brass - Blue Devils/Phantom Regiment/Crown

    Best drums - Phantom Regiment

    Best use of field - Cavaliers

    Top three corps that were hyped and delivered: Phantom Regimnet/Carolina Crown/Cavaliers

    Geoffrey

    PS: answer to the question:Best show - Phantom Regiment

    Best corps - Phantom Regiment

    Bottom line I got from that was that you hate the Cadets.

    You got a little caption list goin there and it has "Best... best best.." then you have "worst" and you put Cadets under both. Oh and you put "best if nothing else mattered"

    I thought this was a best show, best corps thread. If you just don't like the Cadets, you don't have to leak that expression where ever you go.

  8. Huge HUGE Phantom Regiment fan here. But I have to be honest in terms of design....

    Phantom's weak link is visual design. It just isn't ever memorable and thats the problem.

    The Cavaliers, The Cadets, and Santa Clara Vanguard are there every year. And every year, Phantom is not the rave when it comes to drill.

    So far, Phantom's just done a good job with using the drill to make room for staging. It's almost a background. It gets the sophistication, but it ain't gonna get you pulinl out the high camera angles.

  9. The Cadets

    -----

    -plays the most notes out of any hornline while on the move

    -no drumline moves and plays as much as they do (see drumbreak 2007)

    -no guard spins and runs as much as they do

    -consistently moves faster than any other drum corps, year after year

    -most challenging endings i've ever seen

    -amazing work ethic, seeing those kids rehearse is pretty insane

    -jay bocook

    -incredibly out there and different shows

    -members are ALWAYS a class act

    -vintage uniform with french plumes

    i love their show year after year.

  10. http://www.dci.org/news/news.cfm?news_id=f...aa-7db997f679e1

    America’s best high school student musicians to take the field as "2008 All-American Marching Band"

    2/14/2007 -- 3:45 PM CST

    MENC: The National Association for Music Education, has announced a new program to identify the 90 best high school marching musicians for participation in the U.S. Army All-American Bowl, with assistance from Drum Corps International.

    My friend who's been in MENC's Honor Ensembles for many years told me they were going insane. It's a very established program, their high school all-eastern and all-west coast ensembles are considered the best for the secondary education level. But what in the world is this??!?!

    LOOK AT THIS RIDICULOUSLY EXTENSIVE APPLICATION

    http://www.menc.org/allamerican/2008/pdf/2...Application.pdf

  11. I don't think Simple gifts is really that overused. To this day it remains to be my favorite melody.

    Personally I think Simple Gift is done justice not with an orchestra, but with a Drum Corps. Such a melodic song with that aura of an anthem of pride is best expressed with brass in a company front. At least this is all within my opinion.

  12. I don't even know where to begin. You amaze me in your....I don't even know how to describe it.

    The 2007 show WILL be a modern Cavalier show. It will have highly effective drill, music with a catchy tune at some point (or many), with a highly integrated color guard.

    Anything less would be disappointing.

    Of their shows from 2000-2006, I've really only enjoyed 2004. I just don't seem to find the music very enjoyable in the other years. The horns are great the drums are great the drill is great (even though almost all the drill is some form of ripple), but the musical program out of the top 6 has, for me, been consistently bland and lack luster. Not a lot of moving lines or runs for me to really sink the teeth of my ears into.

    But that is just me.

×
×
  • Create New...