LoveKathyG

Members
  • Content Count

    332
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by LoveKathyG

  1. Bluecoats Cavaliers Crown Blue Knights SCV Boston Blue Stars Phantom Crossmen Blue Devils Mandarins Cadets
  2. The judges Money California Stability in staffing Unflinching, unapologetic commitment to winning. They write shows with more focused priority on winning than most other top placing corps. Just enough innovation to win. Just enough art to win. Just enough demand to win. Just enough playing to win. Just enough marching to win. They rarely dabble in anything that's too risky. I don't remember them ever being the most innovative corps any one season. And the few times they have pushed it a bit (e.g. Tommy), they recoil from the placement results and soon veer back to the tried-and-true BD approach. Some will counter to say that other top corps want to win, too. I wholeheartedly agree...and in truth other corps don't win as much because they fail to place as much laser focus on prioritizing wins. If I sound critical of BD, I am. I find this approach rather soulless, but I will never deny their success.
  3. If I were the victim, I would be horrified if YEA or DCI put out a statement. Unless they were authorized or asked by the victim to release a statement and failed to do so, they showed appropriate restraint by staying mum on the topic.
  4. Read “The Art of Community.” Author Charles Vogel talks about the seven principles for building and maintaining community and belonging. He makes the point that every community has membership boundaries. It’s through those boundaries that identity is created. Without the boundaries, the community ceases to know who, what and why it is, and it will fail I think what many are saying is that the boundary of male membership is so core to Scouts that the Scouts community will fail. And I think that’s absolutely right. It will fail. Scouts as we now know them will fail. The question is whether a new community with new membership boundaries that will call itself the Madison Scouts but have totally different boundaries can thrive in its place. That’s the scary part. In an era where there are plenty of other Corps with established communities and in-tact membership boundaries, it’s going to be difficult sell for the Scouts. In essence, they are a new organization.
  5. I thought part of the allure of the multiyear deal with the stadium was that the city was providing DCI with HQ space at a great discount.
  6. Back in the day, lower placing corps, even some of the lower placing World Class corps, would fill holes still vacant in mid-summer by poaching members of smaller corps who were only touring regionally. Does this still happen?
  7. One of the Drunk Corps guys sounds like Seth Rogan. I cannot tell you how much I dislike Seth Rogan.
  8. Color guard "roles?" When did that happen? I marched a spot. I think modern drum corps is too fancy for me.
  9. First thought on Beyonce and Jay-Z... No. Second thought on Beyonce and Jay-Z... Yuck. Third thought on Beyonce and Jay-Z... How many NASA weather balloons could be bought with the money they spent on their 13th home? Values.
  10. First thought... No. Second thought... Yuck. Third thought... How many housing and food insecure people would those things feed a year?
  11. I miss the days when folks were, on the balance, more loyal to organizations that helped them get along in their careers. I get the myriad reasons people err toward looking out for themselves these days. I'm just not sure that mentality is good for anyone...the individual or the organization or the activity. That said, I don't know the the entire story of why SG is leaving SCV for BD. I do acknowledge that.
  12. I'm going to sound like a serious noob, which I'm not. Been around the activity since '83, and I'm a big SCV fan though I didn't march there. But I couldn't figure out what Dan Potter and Michael Boo were talking about when they talked about tons of references to past SCV shows in Babylon. Anyone care to educate me?
  13. I truly don't think I've heard this kind of vitriolic reaction to a medalist show since Star '93...and we know how consensus opinion about that show has evolved over the last 25 years. I hope SCV understands that any questions about their relevance to the activity has been soundly answered with this kind of response...or for some folks will be in a few decades.
  14. I have confidence you'll get it eventually if you keep trying.
  15. Was I the only one who pined a bit for the Ventures, St. Iggies, Mello-Dears, etc. when Crown's all-female ensemble did their thing?
  16. I think you all have missed the point. Vanguard announced their 2018 program on their website months ago. It's "Coming Soon: The Legacies, Legend and Landscapes of Soon Hee Newbold."
  17. YEA needs to move quickly because it's the right thing to do. I'm hoping your first thought was not about saving a year of competition.
  18. If I had my way, all prospectives would be assigned to a corps by the sorting shako. Would love to see what happens if there was more parity.