What I am growing tired of seeing is that the same 12 corps going to finals every year and much is based on this type of scoring. DCI says they want to grow drum corps, but they are driving these kids to NOT be loyal and stay with one corps during their drum corps career. As the kids see it, they may start out in one of the typical bottom seven corps, but if you want to perform on finals night, you need to move to another corps. That doesn't grow the sport of drum corps, it only grows the top 6 or 7 corps. My son marches for Colts and another member went to Cadets this year for that reason. My son is actually a better player and marcher, so in reality, can make it in one of the top corps. But, he loves the staff and family feel of the Colts. However, with the way they score, they tend to start everyone within a point or 2 of where they were at the start of the prior season. So the lower corps can NEVER catch up, no matter how much they improve. It is especially frustrating to the corps that fall in the 13 and 14 spot each year which is where the Colts fall most years.
Now, I'm not an expert, but I believe The Academy has a top 12 show this year. Will the judges deny the Scouts, Boston Crusaders or the Crossmen a spot? I'm not sure. I guess we will see.