Jump to content

Memphis1980

Members
  • Posts

    45
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Memphis1980

  1. 2 minutes ago, BRASSO said:

     While I hear you, do you know how many times over the years that Deb Torchia has been raked over the coals here on DCP for her alleged judge " bias " ? If you are a newbie to DCP you might not be aware of it.  But if you have been on DCP for a few years, you know that this female judge has been publically criticized dozens of times over the years. Hardly a season goes by now that some regular DCP'ers will not single her out... by name on here... for this alleged " bias ". So its rather peculiar that suddenly NOW we are being asked not to go public with any OTHER judge names that might have some " Ageism " issues or " judge bias" issues, or other " issues " regarding their judging.

    Agreed - I find that unless its the same panel or a dual panel with high-low averaging, or a change in how soon an active judge can consult a corps (currently one year off from judging) judging will seem to most as on a whim.  Making the tapes public will not help, judges are very aware that tapes are made public.

    Example, I was sitting right next to the Judging panel at the 2000 DCI Finals in DC, I wish I could find the judge's name next to me. I heard every word, as for her reaction and statements regarding the Cadets, I assumed she placed them first, not so.  She literally was saying one thing and scoring another.

    • Like 1
  2. 5 hours ago, patrick643 said:

     

               Preliminaries - 8/10        

    1 Memphis1980 278.757
    2 barigirl78 276.390
    3 DrumManTx 273.137
    4 Narrow 270.914
    5 FaustianMachine 269.977
    6 Cainan 266.451
    7 AutomaticBloo 259.277
    8 Flguardman 245.932
    9 kwetstein 245.765
    10 WVCorpsPhan 236.107
    11 justMister 221.825

     

    See full recap here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1tF2NqTijWIlSuXA3StSuXDImlJtj9xH7JJHtDoEX3K4/edit#gid=1174612982

    Nice!

  3. → Drag and drop →     Prelim - Thursday 8/10       Semi Final - Friday 8/11       Finals - Saturday - 8/12  
          Corps Score     Corps Score     Corps Score
        1 Blue Devils 97.50   1 Blue Devils 98.0   1 Santa Clara Vanguard 98.20
        2 Santa Clara Vanguard 97.30   2
      Carolina Crown
    97.875   2 Carolina Crown 98.100
        3 Carolina Crown 97.183   3 Santa Clara Vanguard 97.80   3 Blue Devils 98.075
        4 Bluecoats 95.10   4 Bluecoats 95.65   4 The Cavaliers    95.600
        5 The Cavaliers 94.85   5 The Cavaliers 95.05   5 Bluecoats 95.40
        6 Boston Crusaders 93.00   6 Boston Crusaders 93.70   6 Boston Crusaders 94.125
        7 The Cadets 90.85   7 The Cadets 91.90   7 The Cadets 92.0
        8 Blue Knights 91.25   8 Blue Knights 91.60   8 Blue Knights 91.800
        9 Phantom Regiment 89.50   9 Blue Stars 89.80   9 Blue Stars 90.250
        10 Blue Stars 89.45   10 Phantom Regiment 89.725   10 Phantom Regiment 90.0
        11 Crossmen 88.50   11 Crossmen 88.150   11 Crossmen 87.950
        12 Madison Scouts 86.25   12 Madison Scouts 86.750   12 Madison Scouts 84.825
        13 Mandarins 85.50   13 Mandarins 86.700        
        14 The Academy 84.00   14 The Academy 84.625        
        15 Colts 82.50   15 Colts 82.325        
        16 Vanguard Cadets 81.00   16 Vanguard Cadets 81.800        
        17 Troopers 80.50   17 Troopers 81.450        
        18 Spirit of Atlanta 79.325   18 Spirit of Atlanta 80.425        
        19 Blue Devils B 79.10   19 Blue Devils B 79.850        
        20 Oregon Crusaders 78.60   20 Oregon Crusaders 79.275        
        21 Pacific Crest 77.50   21 Pacific Crest 78.400        
        22 Legends 77.00   22 Legends 77.350        
        23 Music City 76.90   23 Music City 76.775        
        24 Genesis 76.20   24 Genesis 75.925        
        25 Seattle Cascades 74.550   25 Seattle Cascades 74.250        
        26 Spartans 74.150                
        27 Jersey Surf 73.625                
        28 Louisiana Stars 73.250                
        29 The Company 72.400                
        30 Gold 71.800                
        31 7th Regiment 70.700                
        32 Guardians 69.800                
        33 Southwind 69.450                
        34 River City Rhythm 67.775                
        35 Pioneer 67.225                
        36 Raiders 64.500                
        37 Shadow 63.250                
        38 Colt Cadets 62.400                
        39 Impulse 59.325                
        40 Les Stentors 56.450                

     

    • Like 3
  4. 3 minutes ago, Treefidy said:

    As I clearly stated THREE OR FOUR people are posting it. It's clear why you, being one of them are posting it, while an overwhelming majority (many of which have seen it in person) disagree completely.

    As far as the humming is concerned...

    Who hummed this on the way home?  But, great show and a winner.

    However,  a great deal of people loved and hummed this show...

     

     

    • Like 1
  5. 1 minute ago, cowtown said:

    As we have all learned, people only like SVC and Bluecoats to spite Blue Devils. If they were truly capable of appreciating Blue Devils’ awesomeness, there would be no lines for all the other, undeserving corps polluting the field with that pedestrian puke called marching

    Perhaps they just like the other corps better because of Blue Devil fans like you.

  6. 4 minutes ago, Ghost said:

    Possibly, but if the content (difficulaty?) doesn't change, then why do the content numbers go up.  As a corps marches and plays better, the achievement scores should improve.

    How insane would the Olympics be if a gymnastics routine, which has been the same, gets a new difficulty rating each round? ... it's nonsense for DCI to prentend that difficulty goes up 25 points in 7 weeks.

    • Like 5
  7. Testosterone! But, not the replacement kind... geodesic domes are cool. Middle horns best in a decade. The three mountains need a color reversal, tge soloists and percussionist get lost. The guard is not timid, very secure in their being. Corps body movement is a bit amped. I can report the narration once again is far more balanced live. IMO, the vocal My Way doesn't add to the show, the horn blast of the same is priceless!

    • Like 6
×
×
  • Create New...