Enough Judging Conspiracy Theories

[Jeff Ream]

12 hours ago, Stu said:

 

Madison Scouts

14^th 1972 3^rd 1973

6^th 1987 1^st 1988

14^th 2002 8^th 2003

15^th in 2009 10^th 2010

Phantom Regiment

23^rd 1972 7^th 1973

11^th 1974 2^nd 1975

10^th 1986 5^th 1987

8^th 1993 3^rd 1993

5^th 1995 1^st 1996

*dropped 1^st 2008 9^th 2009

*also had dropped from 2nd to 10th from 1975 to 1976

02-03...i mean 02 was at the time a fluke. 09, well i think the whole organization wishes to forget that one

 

Phantom was not 2nd in 1975. SCV was. Phantom was 10th, then 4th in 76. Oh yeah they were 14th in 1973

 

but again...no worst to first

[Jeff Ream]

9 hours ago, Stu said:

I watched the Chiefs Seahawks pre-season football game and these observations came to mind: 1) a facemask grab by a Seahawk was missed by the ref but the retaliation by the Chief was penalized (judges do miss things); 2) during a challenge there had to be a determination based on the video if the bobbled ball on a Chief's catch was enough to overturn the call in the field; it was determined that while the ball did move it was considered as still under control (judges call on video replay is still subjective). 3) there has been a rule change on penality of celebration; it will be assessed if it is determined that the offense collectively celebrated or if anyone taunts (complete subjective). And there were many more things which could have been cited. This is all related to DCI in that in all competitive activity there are elements that are both missed and subjective to the play on the field; and for me, I relish the human factor in both the performance and adjudication.

yeah i said that a few pages ago

[Stu]

On 08/25/2017 at 0:31 AM, ContraFart said:

IMO there will never be a corps that goes from 12 to 1 in an single year

 

7 hours ago, Jeff Ream said:

but again...no worst to first

Jeff: When did 12th become 'worst'?

[MikeD]

Locked at the request of the OP