Jump to content

When Judges Go Bad: Who Really Should Have Won


Recommended Posts

I know more than some and less than quite a few but, even with all the knowledge and expertise DCI assembles for Championship week judging, sometimes they just get it wrong.

Fix DCI's Champions list. Rewrite history. Name the corps that should have won but didn't (1995 Blue Devils). Or defend "unpopular" champions that you are certain were indeed the correct choice (2019 Blue Devils). Or don't defend any of your choices. You are king here, and your opinion is beyond reproach.

For me, I went back to 1987, since that is the oldest year I have seen all 12 Finalist shows.

1987 Santa Clara Vanguard
1988 Madison Scouts
1989 Phantom Regiment
1990 Star of Indiana
1991 Star of Indiana
1992 Cavaliers
1993 Cadets
1994 Blue Devils
1995 Blue Devils
1996 Phantom Regiment
1997 Blue Devils
1998 Cadets
1999 Santa Clara Vanguard
2000 Cadets
2001 Cavaliers
2002 Cavaliers
2003 Blue Devils
2004 Blue Devils
2005 Cadets
2006 Phantom Regiment
2007 Blue Devils
2008 Phantom Regiment
2009 Carolina Crown
2010 Blue Devils
2011 Cadets
2012 Carolina Crown
2013 Carolina Crown
2014 Blue Devils
2015 Carolina Crown
2016 Bluecoats
2017 Santa Clara Vanguard
2018 Santa Clara Vanguard
2019 Blue Devils

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1987 Cadets
1988 Blue Devils
1989 SCV
1990 Cadets
1991 Star of Indiana
1992 Star of Indiana
1993 Cadets
1994 Blue Devils
1995 Cavaliers
1996 Phantom Regiment
1997 Blue Devils
1998 Cadets
1999 Santa Clara Vanguard
2000 Cadets
2001 Cavaliers
2002 Cavaliers
2003 Blue Devils
2004 Cavaliers
2005 Cadets
2006 Cavaliers
2007 Blue Devils
2008 Phantom Regiment
2009 Carolina Crown
2010 Blue Devils
2011 Cadets
2012 Blue Devils
2013 Carolina Crown
2014 Blue Devils
2015 Carolina Crown
2016 Bluecoats
2017 Blue Devils
2018 Santa Clara Vanguard
2019 Blue Devils

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Professor!!!! Zoidburg is stirring the pot 😉

Edited by JimF-LowBari
  • Like 1
  • Haha 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The biggest travesty for me was 1989. Granted, SCV’s Phantom of the Opera was a beast of epic proportions, but Phantom Regiment got robbed by .4 points, mainly because SCV played much of the same music from the year before. You can disagree if you like, but my judgement is beyond reproach, according to the post guidelines! 😄

  • Like 6
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, ajlemm said:

The biggest travesty for me was 1989. Granted, SCV’s Phantom of the Opera was a beast of epic proportions, but Phantom Regiment got robbed by .4 points, mainly because SCV played much of the same music from the year before. You can disagree if you like, but my judgement is beyond reproach, according to the post guidelines! 😄

Two of my all time favorite shows are 89 Phantom and 89 SCV, and I can watch them back to back and feel the judges had it right and another time, the judges got it wrong. However, the year I really felt Phantom was robbed was 1979. The musical selection was superb, the color guard was never better, the drill amazing. 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, hostrauser said:

I know more than some and less than quite a few but, even with all the knowledge and expertise DCI assembles for Championship week judging, sometimes they just get it wrong.

Fix DCI's Champions list. Rewrite history. Name the corps that should have won but didn't (1995 Blue Devils). Or defend "unpopular" champions that you are certain were indeed the correct choice (2019 Blue Devils). Or don't defend any of your choices. You are king here, and your opinion is beyond reproach.

For me, I went back to 1987, since that is the oldest year I have seen all 12 Finalist shows.

1987 Santa Clara Vanguard
1988 Madison Scouts
1989 Phantom Regiment
1990 Star of Indiana
1991 Star of Indiana
1992 Cavaliers
1993 Cadets
1994 Blue Devils
1995 Blue Devils
1996 Phantom Regiment
1997 Blue Devils
1998 Cadets
1999 Santa Clara Vanguard
2000 Cadets
2001 Cavaliers
2002 Cavaliers
2003 Blue Devils
2004 Blue Devils
2005 Cadets
2006 Phantom Regiment
2007 Blue Devils
2008 Phantom Regiment
2009 Carolina Crown
2010 Blue Devils
2011 Cadets
2012 Carolina Crown
2013 Carolina Crown
2014 Blue Devils
2015 Carolina Crown
2016 Bluecoats
2017 Santa Clara Vanguard
2018 Santa Clara Vanguard
2019 Blue Devils

so - since I am king

I disagree with your take on 87 - two weeks prior to finals SCV had it. Cadets worked extremely hard and I believe rightfully took it by an inch on finals night. Both were terrific

I agree with 2009 Crown. Looking back I see HOW they were beat - but being there live it was a magical 3 days from Crown & I personally felt they overtook BD at semis and again at finals. I got the feeling the scores just didn't keep up

2007 is the year I disagree with strongly. I know people didn't like the narration - but personally felt that Cadet corps 1-2 pointed BD on finals night. That was a magical performance and even the BD fans around me agreed as did the tv announcers. Still really shocked they didn't take it.

2019 - I felt BD was grossly over scored in GE - JMO. Super clean though!

I otherwise agree with all these - they typically get it right!

Edited by George Dixon
  • Like 3
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, ajlemm said:

The biggest travesty for me was 1989. Granted, SCV’s Phantom of the Opera was a beast of epic proportions, but Phantom Regiment got robbed by .4 points, mainly because SCV played much of the same music from the year before. You can disagree if you like, but my judgement is beyond reproach, according to the post guidelines! 😄

Drums just killed PR imo 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

43 minutes ago, George Dixon said:

Drums just killed PR imo 

Yes, but to my 16 year old mind that year, Regiment was infallible. They were the corps of destiny and were clearly robbed.

Edited by ajlemm
Clarity
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The ones I'd change:

1989 -Phantom Regiment

1996 - no tie, just Phantom Regiment

2008 - Blue Devils (The judges fell for the hype, Phantom was SO dirty. Another emotional win)

2016 - Carolina Crown (DSU had no business winning imo, too dirty. Another emotional win)

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...