Jump to content

Brief Indy Review


Recommended Posts

Well, the day finally came, and I got to see twelve of the best corps in the nation pack themselves into the RCA Dome. This was my first show of the year, and also my last. I'm beginning to really wish I had bought tickets to Madison . . . actually scratch that. I started wishing that a while ago, when I looked on a map and realized how close I really was. However, tonight made me want to see almost every show one more time. On to the Review:

Seats: I ordered ten seats from DCI's website way back in January or February. I asked for the best seats I could get, but in the upper deck. What I got were two rows of five seats, five and six rows back, just a little over from the 40 on side one. Man, they were wonderful. Side one received all the attention, and we could see every set perfectly. The only complaint was the acoustics of the Dome, but I knew that would be a problem when I bought the tickets, so no one to blame but myself

Boston Crusaders

In the very beginning, of their show, they have that same move where they step their left foot forward, then bring it around behind their right leg. I know it's a traditional BAC move, and it was effective the first time, but they did it about five more times in the first minute alone. Overkill. The scrolls didn't make a whole lot of sense. They are unfurled by the guard, revealing phrases such as 'Land of the Free' and 'Home of the Brave', I can only assume to help explain the show. This seems like as good away as any to get around the problem of no voice-overs allowed. I didn't have a problem with the scrolls per se, but how they were used. For example, one scroll was unfurled in the middle of a pinwheeling drill move by the rest of the corps. The guard members had to struggle to keep from getting run over, and the scroll only seemed to distract. Maybe is the scrolls were kept in the front of the field, this wouldn't be a problem. The singing was excellent, they've definitely worked and fine tuned that section. However, in a drum corps show, I think there could have been less of it. It was practically the entire ballad. Singing the words "You are my star" was especially effective, though. My only other complaint was that there wasn't a whole lot of marching. The corps seemed to dance and use body moves to transit sets, at least half the time. I would have preferred to have seen more marching, but still this was a solid corps to open up with. I know I focused on the negative here, but after all, that's easier to remember and describe. Strong performance, about average for what the night would hold, and I thought placed where they deserved.

Spirit

From the very beginning of the show, it reminded me of Avon High School's 2001 show. The same music was used, though certainly Spirit's performance was higher. Still, this show reminded me of a high school group in it's show design. That's not to knock the corps, just classifying it. I was in one of the best high school's in the nation, and was surrounded by excellent groups whenever I competed. Spirit certainly was an excellent group as well, but their show design didn't stand out much for me. I caught the idea of darkness to light, but it could have been emphasized far more. Instead, we saw guard flags, light and dark, but also small and fleeting. I enjoyed their performance, but at least one trademark moment would have helped.

Crossmen

Wow! Cool show. I didn't recognize them at first, because they have a sparkly sash running from shoulder to waist, as the border between the gray and black on their uniforms. The hornline comes into the field from the back right corner, in a revolving gate pattern, the guard comes in from the left corner, and already you're anticipating what comes next. The Metheny piece was very Crossmen. I thought it was an excellent selection to put on the field. Strawberry Soup was very cool to hear, as well. Some interesting drill, and some very cool ensemble work (typical Crossmen) as well in the show. I thought this was a pretty clean show, and deserved a higher score than they recieved, one of the few corps I would say that for. I'd love to see them again.

Colts

Here's where I find myself without much to say. My girlfriend had been at camp all last week, and we hadn't talked all that time. She got back home, just in time to catch me as I was leaving for the Dome. She had tickets as well, though a few sections away from me. Colts was the corps that I ducked out of and went to go find her. No offense to the Colts, but I would do it again in a second :P . It was good to see her again. I do remember hearing the Colts, and recognized it as a Gillingham show rather quickly. However, that's as much as I can say, since I wasn't giving them my full attention.

Seattle Cascades

I'm familiar with the Cadets playing Bernstein, but not familiar enough to the point where I even slightly thought of this as someone else's show. If I were more of a Cadet history buff, I might be bothered, but I viewed this as a uniquely Seattle Cascades show, and as a result, I thourougly enjoyed it. My girlfriend really liked it, too. It was her favorite up to this point. I hear they got a penalty, which would explain their placing not being as high as I would have had them. This was a clean show, with some demanding moments, and you could tell the members had fun performing it. I can't wait to hear from these guys in the upcoming years. The scores would suggest that Seattle has peaked, but trust me, they will be there come finals night. I don't see enough corps better than them for them to finish any worse than top ten.

Bluecoats

Say it with me now, "Bluuuuuuuuuuuuu" I'm not a die hard fan of these guys, but I found myself yelling that out. Try it sometime, it's too much fun to resist. When I read the notes to this show, it reminded me almost exactly of Santa Clara's 2001 show. However, this is very much a different show, done in the Bluecoats character. Enjoyable opener, though not much to say about it. The soloists throughout were d### fine, especially the baritone or mello player. I dubbed him nails. Second best soloist of the night. The guard girl that hangs on him, then ends up slapping his rear had me and my friend laughing. The closer is obviously Daugherty, even if you didn't read the notes. Still, I like the man's work, especially on the field. Bluecoats sold this show well, and completely deserved their placing. Should find themselves squarely on Disc One of the Championship CD's this year.

Intermission

Glassmen

I own the Michael Kamen piece they played, so I was really looking forward to hearing it. However, they played three movements, and the opener and closer were both Javelin. The middle piece was the second movement of Kamen's Symphony, but unfortunately it wasn't the adagio that I loved so much. Rather it was a relatively fast paced ballad. The soloist was back, but this time he certainly didn't receive the emphasis that he did before. It was also a different color of sound than last year, as though he were on trumpet this year. He was in the drill much of the time, so I couldn't really tell. Overall it wasn't necessarily a boring show. However, much of it rides on your opinion of Javelin. Personally I would have liked to see more of the Kamen Symphony, but I'm just one man.

Santa Clara Vanguard

Wow! Again, what a show! This was the most powerful Vanguard show I can remember in quite some time. Add to that the fact that there were numerous characteristic Vanguard moments, and this was a show I loved. In a way, it almost reminded me of the Cavaliers, in that they played obscure and even original music, and matched it with extremely well thought out drill. In fact, besides the Cavaliers, SCV had the best visual design of the night. Despite the obscurity of the music, the show was still very easy to get in to, and I think that was due to the power of the performance. Once they started, you could tell the difference between one of the top four corps, and any other. In my opinion, this show is still a fourth-place show, though it should have been much closer, and there is still much to be cleaned.

Phantom Regiment

Good thing they came on after SCV, because they're opener was loud, and intense, if a little crass. Unfortunately, it was the highlight of their show. The rest of the music is definitely Shostakovich, but doesn't have anywhere near the impact of some of his pieces that have been used in the past. I spent much of my time during this show with my friends, trying to find a good friend of mine in Phantom's guard. We think we did, but there was no way to be sure, since we were just too far away. Well performed, and deserves the lead over Glassmen, but not in the league of the top four, or even of last year's Phantom show, in my opinion.

The Cavaliers

I don't even know where to begin. I guess I should tell you that I watched this corps rehearse that afternoon, working on the opener for a while. I was blown away by their musicianship, and when I saw them in the Dome, that's what impressed me even more than their visual program. There's a chord in their second number that absolutely rang forever in the Dome. No other corps even came close to the sound they acheived. Say what you want about their horn book this year, but the Cavaliers have everyone waxed in music performance, especially in quality of sound, and it's not even close. As for that horn book, I heard a great number of changes since the July 8th show alone. The closer especially received some needed jazzing up. I would suggest to everyone that they wait for the night of Finals to judge this music show, because it keeps getting better and better. The drill . . . well do I even need to say anything? Someone mentioned earlier that the Cavaliers seem to move at a different rate of speed than the rest of the world around them, and that describes it perfectly. No one can match their velocity, or their intricacy either. I sat there the whole time, wondering how anyone could possibly write this. It's amazing. I'm not sure what else to say, other than that you have to see it for yourself. After the corps was done, Jeff Fiedler was interviewed, and someone had the gall to ask if the Cavaliers wouldn't peak too soon. That's something I've never seen the Cavaliers do, and they aren't about to start. Believe it or not, this actually had some of the dirtiest drill from the top four corps. A large portion of the closer, almost half of it, was extremely ragged. I'm guessing this is due to the changes they've made recently, adding in the second Fight Club sequence, but even when entering the first one, they've got some cleaning to do. The amazing thing is, they've already topped 95, and still have a lot of work to do. I don't see how these guys are going to be caught.

The Cadets

I went into this show trying to keep an open mind, and to be honest I wasn't too disappointed. The theme is not nearly as overly patriotic as I'd been hearing. I do think that the pledge is entirely unnecessary. It got a mixed crowd response, but then a large contingent of CadetBorg were on hand that night, too, especially just a few seats away. The "monolith" has three gray rectangle shapes, providing the background for a flag. I was under the impression that there were just two, but apparently one was added, and it was moved upfield. At this point, it only seems to accentuate the flag, and nothing more reprehensible than that. I do think adding the firefighter outfits would be far too much, just as I didn't appreciate the pledge being added, but all in all, this wasn't too patriotic for me. It was definitely a rehash of '95, but what really got to me this year was that the Cadets simply didn't march. Only about half the show consisted of any real sets. The rest of the time the members were taking random scatter drill walks to their next spot. There were no set forms to follow, no spot for them to make, no spacing for them to hold. It was impossible to judge their visual performance, because there wasn't enough precision written in to the show. Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy was d### effective, and even had me toe tapping, but the rest of the show seemed really flat to me, design wise. Maybe the Cavaliers spoiled me, but I thought this show was simply flat random drill, exciting music and theme of show, performed very very cleanly. That seems like it would be enough, but I don't see how they can catch the Cavaliers with this show. In fact, it seems about as clean as it's going to be for the rest of this season. I honestly believe that the Blue Devils will soon catch up to the Cadets, and overtake second place, though Cadets certainly deserved it this night.

Blue Devils

Last show of the night. This show had a lot of circle sets, and I mean a lot. That made it tough to judge their visual, because a circle is the hardest set to clean on the move. As a result, they were pretty ragged. However, I'm of the opinion that this gives them something to still work on. The opener was "feh". Rather forgettable. However, the rest of the show rocked out. BD easily had the best extended soloist of the night. He was showing off a bit too much, in the style of the Cadets, when he ripped the horn off his face three times. However, he was wailing, and proved himself worthy of the "Blue Devils soloist" title. Rising Sun had some of the best moments of the show musically, with power chords that gave me chill bumps. Channel One Suite did, as well, but mainly because I was so familiar with the other shows. After all, Channel One Suite is a part of DCI history. I hear the sideline cymbal set was added just recently, and d### does it work! I couldn't believe the way the battery was flying around, banging away on that thing. There's no way they avoided a collision, it's amazing. Still, there's other visual that needs to be cleaned, and I wouldn't mind hearing a bit more from Channel One Suite, but this is sleezy jazz as only BD can play it, and I really enjoyed hearing it again, after a few years off.

Victory Concert

Stuck around for the standstill of Frameworks. Also heard Washington Post, and Rainbow. Rainbow was what I was there for, and I wasn't disappointed. However, you could tell the kids were getting tired. The tone was spreading the more they played. Still, they managed to make an echo in the dome like no other corps did all night. I would like to have heard Jupiter, but I won't complain. Tried to find that friend of mine back at Pahntom's busses, but the parking garage I was in locked down at 12:30, so I had to book it out of there. It took me another hour at least, just to get home, which was only 12 miles away. Traffic was backed up for miles, because of some silly bicycle ride at 1 in the morning. Utterly ridiculous, but that's an editorial I'm saving for the local paper.

OK, so that wasn't very brief at all, like I claimed in the title. i just started typing, and a lot came out. It was a wonderful show all around, and I just wish I could be there for Madison.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I applaude your review. So far you are in the lead in the contest in my book. But, I am sure you'll have pleaty of compitition after DCI Finals. Me included.

Thought about making the 3 1/2 drive from Chicago but my Saturday chores got in the way.

Thanks!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[ but what really got to me this year was that the Cadets simply didn't march. Only about half the show consisted of any real sets. The rest of the time the members were taking random scatter drill walks to their next spot. There were no set forms to follow, no spot for them to make, no spacing for them to hold. It was impossible to judge their visual performance, because there wasn't enough precision written in to the show.

I'm so glad to see someone say this. All season this has been apparent to me but I thought I was the only one who noticed. The musical program is wonderful and one of my favorites from this group in years, but I wish someone would explain to me how they continue to be placed second when a drill is virtually non-existent for large portions of the show and that which is there is not nearly as complex as other corps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

but what really got to me this year was that the Cadets simply didn't march.  Only about half the show consisted of any real sets.  The rest of the time the members were taking random scatter drill walks to their next spot.  There were no set forms to follow, no spot for them to make, no spacing for them to hold.  It was impossible to judge their visual performance, because there wasn't enough precision written in to the show.  

I don't see enough shows each year to be a critic...I just enjoy the experience. However, I absolutely agree about the Cadets' marching, or lack thereof. I saw them a week ago in San Antonio, and this thought (more or less) went through my mind: "Scatter drills were cool in the mid '80s, but now they are a cop-out for continuity and thought, and really passe'."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great review. I thought Seattle should have been in 10th above Spirit. Their feet are just cleaner, but perhaps because of the lesser demand. I thought Seattle just out performed Spirit last night.

As for the 'Coats, it was a great show last night and they've just begun. If anyone recalls, this is when they really poured it on last year and tightened everything up. They are doing the same thing right now and I think your going to see their GE and Visual numbers jump. I called my shot last week when I predicted they'd catch both Boston and Xmen at this show. I'm sticking with my next prediction as well: they'll catch Glassmen by either Philly or Massillon, and by looking at last night's spreads, maybe before.

Cavies....incredible....I didn't like the color guard incorporation though. It seemed to me that they were really only integrated into the show at the end. It was my first viewing though. Either way, this is far and away the best show in the activity.

Cadets....bringing the house down.

BD...intense, but there's not enough there to catch the teams in front of them.

Just a side note here: it seemed to me that the corps with the white/light/cream color pants "looked" cleaner visually tonight. Everyone (including Cavies) with black seemed to really show the feet a little more. Colts, Cadets, Bluecoats just had a crisp and classy look. I wish more corps would go back to white pants. I think Seattle would do well in white. Or maybe it's just me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jlhiatt:

I beg to differ. Read Adregon's review of the afternoon show and I bet that his evening shows review will match if not surpass his afternoon review.

Those WERE some good reviews, no doubt. But I thought this one was pretty darn good, too.

Let's see how I do with a Drum Beauty review.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Excellent review! I was gonna write one myself, but you took all of the words right out of my mouth. :D I agree, the Cadets do too much scatter drill. Arghh!! Show me somw form retention please! Cavies were awesome, but the dome took away some of their beautiful effects and releases (I was at their practice earlier). Colts actually retained my attention for the first time this years :P . I love Spirit (and a lot of guys from other corps really respect them), but their visuals during the drum break are really bad (like a HS band, sorry). BD got me about half way through the show and kept me till the end. SCV looked like Christmas tree, very precise Chritmas trees at that! A great show, and a great review

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maedrhros wrote:

Colts

Here's where I find myself without much to say. My girlfriend had been at camp all last week, and we hadn't talked all that time. She got back home, just in time to catch me as I was leaving for the Dome. She had tickets as well, though a few sections away from me. Colts was the corps that I ducked out of and went to go find her. No offense to the Colts, but I would do it again in a second . It was good to see her again. I do remember hearing the Colts, and recognized it as a Gillingham show rather quickly. However, that's as much as I can say, since I wasn't giving them my full attention.

I then replied to Jhiatt's response that I did not think it was a good review--

(Yes, I was a bit slighted by Maehdros comments--Not because he did not do a review on the Colts, but because he was disingenuous to all the readers of this forum.

A review is a review of all the corps--he did not review all the corps and I believe that his comments regarding why he did not see the Colts was disingenuous--

Hear me out on my rationale and what Maedhros stated:

How much of a girlfriend was she?

a. She caught you as you were walking out the door to go to the dome. You must have been in a rush to get to the show that you could not speak with her then, but then all of a sudden you decided to speak with her during the show? That does not pass the goofy test.

b. You had not spoken to her in a week and the urge just came over you during the fourth corps of the competition to go speak with her. My daughter went to cheerleading camp (I hate to admit that, but I have to address this point). She spoke to her boyfriend while she was gone more than she spoke with me or her mother. I am assuming that the band camp that your girlfriend went to must have been run like the Navy Seals training session. No contact with the outside. h###, criminals I put away get daily phone privileges and have more access to a phone than your girl friend at band camp--I should inform the judicial system that we are treating our students in band camp in Indiana more harshly than the inmates in federal prison. In other words, if you were in such a rush to get to the show then to speak with her, then what came over you to speak with her during the competition. Why did you not go look for your girlfriend before the show even started? How much of a girlfriend is she that she never called you or you her?

c. If she is so much of a girlfriend why did you

1) not go to the show together and

2) have seats together.

It reminds me of the scene in "Field of Dreams" were Ray Kinsella is looking for Terence Mann and Kinsella goes up to a gent on the street and asks this guy for the address of where Mann lives. The man asks Kinsella why he wanted to know-Kinsella says he, Mann, is a friend of mine, then the guy retorts, "If he is friend of yours why didn't he give you the address."

Why do you just not come right out and say the Colts bore the h### out of you and decided to go get a hot dog. (When I marched with the corps it was not uncommon to see the mad dash of folks to the concession stand as we entered the field of competition--it was rather entertaining to see the people run over each other to get to the exits).

You can't bs a bs'er. The problem with your post was that you were not being truthful. Maehdros, yes, I am upset with you, but just tell it the way it is--the truth hurts, to lie or couch what you really mean or did in uncertain terms will get you hurt or in trouble in the long run. We are all big people on this board. Call a spade a spade. If the Colts suck, say so. If you went to go get a hot dog, say so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...