Jump to content

Just Another Mell

Members
  • Posts

    11
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Just Another Mell

  1. However, I will say, the original poster's question does deserve some wonderment. I mean, it's not like one judge saw a corps as 1st place and the other judge saw it as 2nd place. If the division really is that wide where one judge saw Corps A as first place and Corps B as last place, and the other judge saw the exact opposite, it's worth wondering.

    I think that cire is talking about the Effect Scores for Class A where this did happen.

    Visual Effect 1 Dream 1st

    Visual Effect 2 Dream 3rd

    Music Effect 1 Dream 3rd

    Music Effect 2 Dream 1st

  2. It's all good. We'll see how things shape up on Sept. 1st :) FWIW, I think the majority of scores on here (lower Open Class and most of Class A) are suspect at best. We do not yet have the consistency in judging across the country like DCI has. I really look at this year and next year as a break-in phase for the DCA Sheets in shows outside the original DCA Boundaries.

    While I agree that it doesn't matter until we all meet.

    The West Coast Corps have been on the DCA sheets for 2 years now, do you really think its going to take another one before the scores aren't "suspect"?

    While last year was alittle rough, this year, I believe, that this year the numbers do stand for themselves.

  3. Ryan, I understand (thanks to your explanation) the new script....but I STILL wanna hear the tradition "are the judges/corps ready...Corps X, you may take the field..." announcements.

    I certainly don;t mind the extra warmup time...although i DO wish more corps would take advantage of it....it's the script itself that -- frankly -- sucks major ###.

    Well if Sam doesn't like it, I guess DCI should just change it right now

×
×
  • Create New...