Jump to content

SCTuba

Members
  • Posts

    417
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by SCTuba

  1. In 2011 at this time Cadets scored a 71.05 at fortworth while Cavies, Crown, and BD all scored over 74. In August they won it all.

    Now, For Bluecoats to be 2.15 behind Crown at this time of the season should not mean they are now out of the race. I have a Cadets 2011 feeling with Bluecoats this year. The show is there, clean clean clean and it will be a monster to contend the title in August. It has happened before in what can be argued less favorable circumstances. And it should be noted that Cadets didn't win a single regional in 2011 until the Sunday after Allentown at the TOC show.

    And if the 2011 analogy holds it will mean that Cadets will pull a "Cavies" and slide back into third/4th by July.

    I was also about to make this point. I don't think it's time just yet to write Bloo off. They've got a solid product that I could definitely see the crowd getting behind. If they just continue to plug away, clean and add and do their thing they could find themselves within a point or so of 1st by the time the last week of the season rolls around with some huge forward momentum going their way. So long as they pace it so they don't plateau this thing could go all the way I think. The progression of this season should be interesting and fun to watch at the very least.

    • Like 1
  2. To a limited degree its already been done . . .

    I think Milton HS? (north Atlanta area) did a show last year that used LED lights in the bells of the brass instruments and on the woodwinds.

    Probably weren't the first . . . someone on the BOA/WGI circuit?

    Kennesaw Mountain High School had LED lights on their uniforms and props last year. WCU used them on their drumline last year too, although that's been referenced many times on this forum.

  3. I would LOVE to see Crown do some of David Diamond's Symphony no. 2 Movement 4. A piece not as well known as some and there could be some potentially FANTASTIC brass moments taken from It.

    I've only heard vague things about Diamond before now, so at your mentioning this I looked the piece up. WOW. There's fantastic material throughout the entire work that could provide enough to make an absolute home run of a drum corps show. It's like Copland meets Bruckner meets a movie score feeling meets the awesome flair of the 20th and 21st centuries with a whole bunch of other things thrown in. This stuff needs to get put on the field. thumbup.gif

  4. From my own observations seeing everyone live, I'd have to give it to The Cadets. Their hornline as a whole was extremely solid, but their low brass was fantastic. A dark, rich sound while still maintaining plenty of clarity, which adds a huge amount of depth to the overall sound of the hornline IMO.

  5. I'd say it's pretty likely there's a large number of music majors in corps nowadays. Drum corps experience is a HUGE plus for anyone looking to apply to teach band at the high school level, especially at schools with bands that perform on competitive circuits. It gives candidates a different experience than what they get at college (which is where most drum corps participants get their formal symphonic training, at least in undergrad) and lets them bring a much more diverse skill set to the table vs. other candidates. I also wouldn't be surprised if the percentage from BITD was a bit higher than you think as I've heard of many musicians and music educators nowadays who marched corps in the early 90s and farther back. As the activity has progressed it has become more viable and practical for the college music major to participate in for various reasons, and thus the percentage has increased over the years to the point where it is now (and I would assume it will at least stay around the same level if not continue to increase).

  6. What about a smaller school that has, for instance, a great engineering program and also a music program? Is it possible that he could get a music scholarship recognizing his talents but be enrolled for the engineering curriculum? Or would he have to be a music major to get a music-based scholarship?

    From what I've seen in my experiences and knowing people from multiple institutions, you don't have to be a music major to get a music-based scholarship. Most of the time they will require some level of participation within the music program (which could vary anywhere from simply taking lessons to having some ensemble involvement depending on what instrument the audition was on), and most of the larger scholarships will more than likely be reserved for the music majors enrolling in the school, but I've still known non-majors to get rather sizable awards for music simply by being able to walk into their auditions and blow the faculty away, which I'd imagine your son will be able to do easily if he's already able to play Rach on piano. smile.gif So the short answer is yes, and he can actually earn a TON of scholarship money from having the boost from a music scholarship and being an engineering major, which can earn lots of money and incentives depending on what the institution has to offer.

  7. This is the photo ashevillemurphy was referring to:

    303070_10151590031617641_1600131323_n.jpg

    As difficult for me as this is, I'm going to wait for an official announcemt from Crown before I sound off on weather or not I do or don't like this uniform.

    The headgear here reminds me of what Ronald Reagan HS from San Antonio wears.

    ronald-reagan-2012a.jpg

    This is the best picture I could find. You can kind of see how it looks in the background, and Jolesch has some pictures as well that it can probably be seen better in. That was the first thing that entered my mind when I saw the sketch, not sure how indicative it is of Crown's choices for this year.

  8. -3.) This is not relevant to the first two but I figured I'd ask it here rather than open another thread, but I've heard that if you're auditioning for Bluecoats, they don't take you as a rookie/someone with no previous drum corps experience. Does anyone know how much truth there is to this?

    Total rumor. I've known 3 guys that got spots in the Bluecoats' hornline as rookies with only high school marching experience. Coming prepared for your audition and showing a good attitude and work ethic can compensate for a lack of experience a lot of the time from what I've observed/heard about.

    • Like 1
  9. He was truly an inspiration, every recording of the CSO from his era absolutely blows me away. We've lost a fantastic player, pedagogue and person today. I wish I could've had the opportunity to meet him and have a lesson with him, it would have been an incredible experience. RIP Bud, you will be missed by the entire music community.

  10. Crown 2009 and 2012 definitely deserve a mention. I don't think the spreads justify the difference between the shows (especially this past year), though I don't necessarily disagree with the placements. One that I personally really enjoy as well is Phantom 2006, and any other year that show would have won, but Cavies that year were just crazy amazing. It was still remarkably close though and really could've gone either way depending on how you look at it.

    • Like 3
  11. Everything I need to know, I learned in music class.

    This is an extremely excellent article I hope you read, and there are plenty of comments directly related to drum corps.

    He talks about what we cut when money is tight. Drum corps is going through that talk right now. He talks about job security. Ditto about drum corps as an entity. Critical thinking skills? Drum corps offers that to no end. Hard work paying off? Indeed. Making it happen? Yep. Knowing where you stand? The essence of competition. Making connections and learning to work with others, as well as taking responsibility for your work? Oh, baby.

    And focus on the paragraph that reads, "When you're performing music, you can't cheat. You can't say to the audience, "You don't get it." If they didn't understand it or like it, you failed." Haven't we discussed this at length over the past few years?

    I hope you find this short article as captivating as I have, and see many parallels to what we're doing with drum corps.

    This article needs to get some serious views nationwide. Brilliantly written with some very excellent points. Great find Mr. Boo.

    • Like 1
  12. As for the value of marching band in particular for the college music ed. major, there is no question that one gains a deeper understanding of the activity from direct participation (providing the instructional level is professional). In addition, if one seeks a secondary school position, the chances for employment are greatly enhanced for the candidate in posession of these skills.

    I wasn't necessarily questioning the value of having a solid understanding of marching band for music education majors, I was more questioning of the value that participation in college marching band would bring, especially being required to do multiple years. High school marching band and college marching band have become rather different beasts for the most part and are taught in rather different manners. Whereas a college band will learn a new show pretty much every week for the weekend's game, a high school marching band (at least in a corps-style program) will have a single, much more involved show that is cleaned over the entire season. Participation in college marching band does hold some value in teaching how to instruct and clean very quickly in a short period of time, but it doesn't impress upon future band directors the skills needed to clean shows that can have up to 10 times more sets of drill and more musical challenges that accompany the concept of first pacing out the learning of the program itself, and then to not only keep cleaning the show but to also keep tweaking based on observation in rehearsal/competition and also adjusting elements of the show based on comments from adjudicators. There's only so much that college marching band can teach that applies to the real world. Serving one year makes the most sense to me, but beyond that seems like it gets redundant and can only have so much real-world value beyond that first year (the law of diminishing returns in action). Then again, most of what needs to be known to be a successful band director is learned outside of the college classroom anyway, so maybe I'm making a moot point anyway. tongue.gif

  13. Heard this on NPR earlier this week.

    http://www.npr.org/2...unct-for-sports

    The article has received a relatively large number of comments on the NPR website. Basically, the commentator is upset with what he feels is an overblown emphasis on marching band within High School and College music programs.

    What do you think?

    Here's my take, as I've been part of two parts of his point and have first hand experience with it (though these are just my opinions). I'll start with the point about him talking about high schoolers being forced to do marching band to be in the concert band program as well. My high school went by this system, and it has its merits and pitfalls. The main benefit it provided is that all the top players were on the field, so naturally there was some assured strength and musical leadership on the field. The main flaw in this idea is a lot of kids only wanted to be in concert band, and resented having to do marching band. Quite a few wouldn't have been there if they didn't have to. It's a touchy subject once you start asking if marching band should be required or not for high schoolers enrolled in a band program. For one, marching band can be an EXTREMELY positive experience for students, in musical, physical, mental, and emotional aspects, and can provide for many students a certain intangible value that can be crucial to a student's musical education. Most people I've run into that did it in high school at least enjoyed it, if not loved it, even if they didn't decide to pursue it later whether through college marching band or corps. There is that smaller population to be accounted for though, and that's where problems are run into, but an all-volunteer system isn't *always* the solution. There are many highly successful programs around the county (Broken Arrow Senior High from Oklahoma is one that comes straight to mind) that are entirely based on volunteer participation, but the main issue with this approach is that some students may never give it a chance, so they may never discover that they enjoy it and may miss out on some significant personal and educational experiences. So there's where the two approaches reach an impasse. But as far as the article's point of high school marching band being used as a secondary form of entertainment at football games is a crazy overstatement. For the most part (the "show band" tradition is a prime exception to this), high school marching band shows are not something that would be considered "entertaining" by the average spectator at a football game, at least in the sense of what they imagine a football halftime show to be. Most high school bands are more focused on using those performances as opportunities to perform in public and are more concerned with success on their respective competitive circuit(s). So as far as that point goes, I think it falls kind of moot at a certain point.

    As for there being an overemphasis on college bands being a secondary entertainment, I have pretty mixed feelings on this. First of all, it is a tradition that many college football fans are astoundingly passionate about, so it definitely serves a purpose that is seen as significant by the viewing population, so I feel while it is "secondary", it is also strongly valued, along with the presence in the stands during gameplay. The place where I start to agree with the article is where it says students are awarded music scholarships for marching band to reward their performance more than enhance their music education. To start off, most members of college marching band aren't there to further their music education. They're there because they enjoyed marching band in high school and wanted to continue in college, or because their family members did it/friends are doing it currently, or even just to get a scholarship and free football. Then there's a fixture within college bands that runs into some opposition a lot of the time, and that's the requirement of music education majors to do marching band for a certain number of years to earn credit towards their degree, which can range anywhere from 2-4 seasons from what I've observed/heard. I fall into this category, and I can say from my experience and from talking to my fellow music ed majors that it really does nothing to enhance our musical education. It provides no experience that teaches us anything we wouldn't have learned in high school or would learn in our "Marching Band Techniques Class" we're required to take. All it really does is take time out of our already packed schedules which makes fulfilling our practicing and studying commitments all the more difficult. Out of everyone I've seen drop music ed and either switch to another music degree or to another field of study all together, the requirement to do marching band was a pretty significant reason why (though there were others of course). So I guess on one hand I agree with the author, but at the same time I feel like some of his opinions are a little harsh and critical of the role of marching band on both levels.

    Ok. Rant over.

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...