Jump to content

Tone Quality Matters

Members
  • Posts

    1,418
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Tone Quality Matters

  1. Considering they are sitting in 11th right now, they will likely move up a couple spots.

    Considering they are sitting in 11th right now, they will likely move up a couple spots.

    I agree that the product is a step up, the execution hasn't been all summer. I think they stay in that general area

  2. There are a lot of individual performer errors in this Boston show tonight. That said, it's really on another level design-wise compared to the corps before them (except Blue Stars). If they can clean it, they can move past a few big names.

    Explain yourself please. I don't see it going any further than it will tonight

  3. There are arguments on both sides of this one. I think it boils down to the individual and where their heart is. If you have the talent to march 3-4 top 6 corps and that is what you desire, then you should do it. The activity benefits from your talents at several destinations.

    There is something large to be said about loyalty though. Crown is where I marched and who I love. I love the organization, it's people and it's vision for young people. I am a better person for having marched there and knowing and loving my extended family.

    I do challenge each to find a home though after age out. Every corps needs you!

    Either way, a win/win for drum corps :cool:

  4. I tried to contact them but I got bounced.

    No question there is ZERO truth to this statement. This staff, this organization would certainly not simply "bounce" a concern brought up from anyone.

    This being said, and my feeling about this goes for all of the teams out there. Let's leave design opportunities or concerns to the staffs who have been living, eating and breathing the show and concept, well since August of the previous season or longer. We as fans can postulate with each other what would be better but is nonsense to think we should tell a given staff how to do something

  5. I honestly believe Crown, BD & Cadets and Bloo are a cut above the rest of the teams, and these four fabulous shows will kick it into high gear and there is no way we will know a clear winner until very close to Finals. What you have are four outstanding shows, wonderfully, uniquely designed and performed at such a high degree of energy and execution that they will all trade spots often. All four shows are already championship worthy.

    No dig on the rest of the teams out there but these four are trully amazing.

    • Like 5
  6. What bothers DCP doesn't necessarily come in to play with judges.

    If the design team hears about transition pacing in critique or on a tape, then there perhaps there will be changes. But if the adjudicators are buying the explanation the corps is selling, you won't see changes.

    But you can't always assume that what irritates DCP users always bothers the judging community.

    :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup: What he said!!

  7. what defines the second tier?

    seems like last season there are tiers, groups. A gulf of separation between groups of corps at different performance/execution levels at this point. Last summer, you could see a clear separation of execution/ quality from corps 1-3, 4-6, 7-8, and 10-12. Tonight, there was a distinct separation from Crown to Phantom. Of course the corps in these groups change often early in the season

  8. so people were putting PR in 9th and they are only 3 points behind Crown that people put in first. They clean that drumline and they can be up in the top and shock alot of people. Would have been great to hear them without echo.

    Phantom is a second tier corps at this moment (4-6) range. Certainly not a ninth place corps. That's nutts

×
×
  • Create New...