Jump to content

Guard-ian

Members
  • Posts

    134
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Guard-ian

  1. no way that scv brass is .6 ahead of cavaliers. dont know that judge is smoking. and cavalier guard should not be scoring that low in guard they have had better scores and havent lost to crown in that really that much at all all season.

    oh well. lol

    Welcome back Debbie Torchia to the world of drum corps. We've missed you......well, maybe not!

  2. Wow guys, the answer is simple. Regionals have full panels. DCI West was a regional. Normal was not.

    Therefore, but the Duh's Law:

    DCI West -> Full panel

    Normal -> Not a full panel

    </thread>

    The panel for the Stockton show

    Brass Performance Mark Petrash

    Guard Curtis Costanza

    Music Ensemble John Bell

    Ensemble Visual Dan Smith

    Music Effect Jay Webb

    Percussion Dan Bryan

    Visual Effect Scott Pizani

    Visual Performance Ed Warren

    Is Stockton a regional for DCI too?

  3. I think at times, it's easier to blame something/someone else (in this case the judges) for the shortcomings of our favorite corps. Every year, corps make choices. In the long run, those choices turn out to be correct or incorrect depending on the end of the season outcome. Some corps don't care, some do care and some say they don't care, but they really do. The bottom line is you live or die by the choices you make.

    The judges are an easy target, but I doubt they care what happens outside of a contest. They have a vested interest in the activity, but in one particular corps....I don't think they'd expend the energy needed to target a particular corps for failure.

    Food for thought.

    :tongue:

  4. For what it's worth, not until I saw Phantom's show last night did I fully comprehend the story (being unfamiliar with Spartacus). I saw the show live and from my perspective, unless you know what to look for, it's not as clear as many think it is. I didn't even notice the drum major getting killed until after the fact, as I was watching the corps proper instead. Last night the cameras highlighted the most important elements of the storyline, which made it much easier to understand.

    That said, I don't think it's possible to tell a clear story through a corps performance to an unfamiliar audience on the first read. Cadets' 08 story was very clear because they literally told you what it was. Even Crown 07 I didn't make the connection about the photo finish until they added the amplified voice. I'm not saying that amplified voice should be used to tell a story, just that it's the only guaranteed effective way to do so. Otherwise, corps need to rely on nuances and detail throughout the production and hope they get noticed. DCP even plays a role here where one fan notices something and tells the masses to look for it, which increases the effectiveness of the show from a fan's standpoint. What separated Phantom's show was that so much of it was over the top, turning it into a borderline theatrical production. It made for a great drum corps show don't get me wrong, but I don't think I would be pleased if the majority of corps started putting faux musicals on the field.

    Lastly, I just want to say that I would rather watch a show without vocals and not fully understand it until seeing the video or until I listened to the director's commentary than listen to a very obvious show with vocals. But hey, that's my personal preference.

    I am familiar with the story and am still wondering why they killed the conductor....it wasn't in the story I read. Was he rushing the tempo?

  5. I think that practice died along with DCM.

    Personal Opinion: Having been brought up Catholic, prayer is nothing new to me, however, making a big deal about it on the 50 yd. line, kind of defeats the purpose. If you want to pray with your friends, do it by the buses where it is a private time between you, your friends and The Lord.

×
×
  • Create New...