Jump to content

luvs me sum mello!

Members
  • Posts

    1,793
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Posts posted by luvs me sum mello!

  1. :thumbup: Once and Always!! We have a couple of brothers from my chapter marching different corps. I know last year the Chapter at UT Arlington set up a get together step sing after the Dallas show last year. It would be nice to meet brothers throughout the summer!

    Juan

    Planning on doing it again this summer!

  2. With all due respect to great University bands....the answer is none. Although many bands have great directors, awesome writers and talented members, they are made to entertain at football games and provide a part time experience for students. Drumcorps requires grit and determination often under tough circumstances, a university band would crumble under the daily pressures of touring in the summer.

    As proven by Jacksonville State University, long term support for a creature such as a drumcorps does not jibe with the mission of a university or college.

    Not true. My alma mater has no football team and hasn't for over 25 years. The marching band is not a "part-time" experience. While it may not consume near the time DC does, it functions as a lab for music education majors and as an ambassador for the university. Of course it would be difficult...but most things worth doing are.

  3. The University of Texas at Arlington. They have a corps style band and no football team. Haven't since 1985. They're marching with Scouts 2008 instruments, complete with contras. Given some more funding (and more then 6 hours a week rehearsal), it'd be an easy transition/addition.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-kMBIKXQ6w

    Drumline this past season: http://www.youtube.com/user/UTArlingtonMusic?blend=1&ob=5#p/c/C5D0BBCFD51E0DD5/6/LIjFbn68g-4

  4. LOL. Yes, I think his son is about six years in on an eight year run as a Blue Stars marching member. So, yes, there are a few long timers out there, but nothing like the old days. Just too great a commitment to march multiple years these days.

    I hardly think it's too much of a commitment (suggesting kids these days don't commit), but that it is far more difficult for a 14 or 15 year old to make a top-tier corps and then march there for the whole time. In Kris's case, he made the Blue Stars back before anyone in the stands thought they had a chance in (then) Div 1.

  5. I have noticed that some here don't like the idea of a discussion forum where they may have to actually read what other people think about something. A few things:

    1) If opposing discussion were not heard would amplification be judged this year? (I don't mean simply DCP BTW)

    2) Would the forum be boring because it would be nothing more than a general back patting and re-affirmation feel good place?

    People never read anything longer then a couple sentences. And even if they read your well thought out, well written argument on X, they will pick one thing (usually having nothing to do with the core of the argument) and pick on that.

    1) Nothing would change if this forum didn't exist.

    2) No.

  6. 1. G bugles sound awesome when they are played correctly, just like anything else

    2. false, false, and false.

    corps today aren't as loud, period.

    any better balancing isn't due to horn key...it's just due to better balancing. the two aren't synonymous.

    if you don't like the overtones of G bugles, then I suppose you will think tone quality is better, but once again, tone quality is a product of playing, not what you are playing on.

    No they don't. They have pitch issues and good luck tuning a line. I've heard the USMC Band play them live and, while I am a huge fan of the USMC concert ensembles, the drum corps is not that impressive. They stick to heritage and don't have to compete, so why switch?

    You obviously equate crass with loud. Yes, yesterday's corps were far more abrasive, but today's corps are louder. Better tuning and better balance makes for a louder sound. Physics win.

    It isn't? G bugles are more difficult to tune within sections and across the line and in order for the low brass to hold down the very bright, very shrill sopranos, they have to blow their guts out and get a nasty sound. Orchestration 101.

    We have decades of just horrible playing on G bugles next to near 2 decades of superior playing on Bb.

    So I ask again: If things are better, why go back? And no, just because the tint of your rose colored glasses is getting astoundingly dark doesn't count.

    • Like 2
×
×
  • Create New...