Jump to content

Bob J

Members
  • Posts

    1,067
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Bob J

  1. snipped.

    Yeah, if you have a decent piano player it could be a sweet addition. Too bad no woodwinds....nothing like that clarinet solo to kick things off. It may be one of two or three clarinet solos I can stomach. But, either they dump it off on a patch for the keyboard player or they mash it into a horn part. Get the guy from Blue Stars to march Scouts this year and take the woodwind use penalty. Now that...would be ballsy.

    This!

    I think the move to woodwinds is inevitable (kind of like the vocal "Amen" from Garfield and the "Axel Foley" thing from BAC back in the day). Embrace it, and I'll bet the judges reward would offset the penalty.

  2. Tekk

    Perhaps its not because you aren't a cymbal player, but because you marched in an era and with corps that did not fully use/appreciate the instrument. With the 2000 Cadets representing the epitome of the activity, one probably doesn't see the need or value of a plate line. To others who marched back in the day, or tend to lean to the more traditional aspects of the activity, taking the cymbals off the field is tatamount to blasphemy. It is simply an issue of different frames of reference.

  3. Sounds like the process of concluding that man has contributed to Global Warming, all the way down to calling it science, and assigning the word "sheep" to it!

    Consensus and Computer Models.

    Neither of which have anything to do with science. Sure, Computer Models are a tool in science, but not when making unprovable conclusions, and then (worse) making policies based on them. Pure politics. All driven by money, and NOT science.

    Precedent? Sure...Galileo and Einstein....two guys who went against the consensus, and used actual science.

    But I digress.

    I use the scientific process (Observe, Hypothesis, Test) outlined in Competitive Inertia. Note that Crown's rise has confirmed the hypothesis, 2 years after Competitive Inertia was written. In fact, they were cited in the original post:

    http://www.drumcorpsplanet.com/forums/inde...howtopic=107285

    Then you'll be happy to know how poorly this method worked for me last year! I (we) had Phantom in 4th, Crown in 5th, Madison in 10th and Troopers in 16th. Shows how much we know.

  4. Let us all please keep in mind how well we did last year with our predictions. I collected all the posted predictions from the threads last year and put them in a spreadsheet to find a consensus average. As a group, we thought Phantom would finish 4th, Madison would finish 10th, Spirit would finish 14th, and Troopers would finish 16th. At least we got Pioneer and Cascades right!

×
×
  • Create New...