Underrated: Blue Stars, Madison, maybe BK or Boston
BY FANS:
Overrated: Colts, Academy, Cavaliers, SCV
Underrated: Cadets, Glassmen, maybe Phantom
I know it may seem incongruous that I put Cadets underrated by fans and overrated by judges, but it's really not... I'm not sure I'd have put them second, but people were just way too critical of them. Yes, I was mad that the music was covered by narration, but when they took it out, it wasn't like a TON was cut out... and at least they addressed the issue. Also, when I was sitting at finals, a boy was narrating (one of the more serious narrations in the show) and someone sitting by me screamed "GET ON THE PLANE!" I'm sorry, but that's uncalled for. The kid was dutifully following what his techs had told him to do... even if it wasn't directed just at that kid, I can't imagine how crushing it would be to have that kind of jeering audience response after you have given everything you have all summer. And I'm saying that as someone who is not a Cadets fan.
Most overrated and underrated shows of 2007
in DCI World Class Corps Discussions
Posted
BY JUDGES:
Overrated: Colts, Academy, maybe Cadets
Underrated: Blue Stars, Madison, maybe BK or Boston
BY FANS:
Overrated: Colts, Academy, Cavaliers, SCV
Underrated: Cadets, Glassmen, maybe Phantom
I know it may seem incongruous that I put Cadets underrated by fans and overrated by judges, but it's really not... I'm not sure I'd have put them second, but people were just way too critical of them. Yes, I was mad that the music was covered by narration, but when they took it out, it wasn't like a TON was cut out... and at least they addressed the issue. Also, when I was sitting at finals, a boy was narrating (one of the more serious narrations in the show) and someone sitting by me screamed "GET ON THE PLANE!" I'm sorry, but that's uncalled for. The kid was dutifully following what his techs had told him to do... even if it wasn't directed just at that kid, I can't imagine how crushing it would be to have that kind of jeering audience response after you have given everything you have all summer. And I'm saying that as someone who is not a Cadets fan.