Jump to content

cgmomma

Members
  • Posts

    62
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by cgmomma

  1. It is true that CG scores can be subjective and inconsistent from judge to judge. I have numbers for six of the Crossmen/Blue Stars match-ups prior to Indy and in four contests, Crossmen beat the Blue Stars in CG. In two, the Blue Stars beat the Crossmen. BS did beat the Crossmen in that caption at semis. If it means anything, Mike Lentz had put the Crossmen over BS in the previous two shows he judged both corps. So, it was a small turnaround for him.

    I actually wasn't comparing them just with the Crossmen. I have had trouble with many contests along the line, especially those I saw live mid-July and then again finals week. Although Crossmen is clean, I do not believe their, and many others, vocabulary/cleanliness ratio is above the Blue Stars.

    • Like 1
  2. While I do give Crossmen their due credit because they were truly ON Friday night, and I do concede that Blue Stars had some issues they were not able to overcome in time, one thing I can not swallow is the score/placement that the Blue Stars color guard received that night. To use wesleyrp's words "a scan of Twitter comments and even the semis thread here will reveal what most people thought of their performance that night", that guard was on fire Friday. I was there Thursday, Friday and Saturday, sitting with other color guard instructors and judges. Sorry, Blue Stars was NOT a 12th place color guard. They were 9th the night before (with a weaker performance than Friday) and have ranked as high as 6th or 7th (if memory serves) throughout the season. THAT would have put them into finals.

    • Like 6
  3. Reacted to it when it happened, but re-watching semi's I was just reminded of how tacky it was that Dan Potter thought it appropriate to conduct the only on-field interview of a drum major just coming down from the podium after Friday night's performance with the Crossmen drum major as the Blue Stars were taking the field. It's as if the decision had already been made. He couldn't do that interview after both sets of scores were announced? I'm sure the drum major would have been thrilled to accommodate.

    Really DCI????

    • Like 2
  4. Random question --- how is performance order determined on Thursday in Indy?

    From DCI.org:

    Performance order for the World Class portion of the following Prelims lineup was determined by the average scores from San Antonio, Texas (July 21), Atlanta, Ga. (July 28) and Allentown, Pa. (Aug. 3-4). The Open Class portion will be determined by the results of the Open Class Finals on Tuesday, Aug. 7 in Michigan City, Ind.

    Read more: http://www.dci.org/news/view.cfm?news_id=86588617-6e58-4001-be22-f3624d433c50#ixzz22iJkgxN6

  5. Tee hee Jon. I'm doing this for Robyn, because you know how she loves to correct spelling errors. The title of the song is "Rockin' Robin". Although, I'm sure she'd be pleased you used the spelling of her name. lol

    everytime i look at the title i start getting "rockin robyn" stuck in my head!

  6. We had trouble with these rifles breaking, always in the same spot, at the neck. To be fair, it was one of the earliest versions. Don't use them anymore. Bandshoppe did, however, replace every rifle that broke.

    Also, the newer versions had a slight texture to them which some tapes didn't stick to very well.

    Good Luck!

×
×
  • Create New...