Jump to content

jthomas666

Members
  • Posts

    590
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by jthomas666

  1. 2 hours ago, barigirl78 said:

    While judges do see the shows several times, I think they are intended to judge the performance that is in front of them.  At some point in every season, they are seeing a corps for the first time.  DCI tries to rotate judges to different captions over the course of a season.

    There were two judges in Finals--Rothe and Romanowski--that only judge three shows prior to Finals.  Rothe saw SCV twice before.  Romanowski saw them only once prior to finals.

    I don't know to what degree judges watch shows when they aren't judging.  Are they supposed to?  But, it's not a given that they've seen the shows more than the fans have.

     

    OK, thanks for the info.  I was under the impression the judges saw the shows on a more regular basis.

    And just so we're clear, I am not implying any sort of dissatisfaction regarding SCVs show.  Yes, I'm not familiar with any of the music, but it is growing on me.  And the musicianship on display was unreal.

  2. 2 hours ago, barigirl78 said:

    While judges do see the shows several times, I think they are intended to judge the performance that is in front of them.  At some point in every season, they are seeing a corps for the first time.  DCI tries to rotate judges to different captions over the course of a season.

    There were two judges in Finals--Rothe and Romanowski--that only judge three shows prior to Finals.  Rothe saw SCV twice before.  Romanowski saw them only once prior to finals.

    I don't know to what degree judges watch shows when they aren't judging.  Are they supposed to?  But, it's not a given that they've seen the shows more than the fans have.

     

    OK, thanks for the info.  I was under the impression the judges saw the shows on a more regular basis.

  3. On 8/12/2018 at 7:16 AM, 2000Cadet said:

    While I think their show was fantastic, I hope it is unique to them and no one else. I like a little variety in my life.

    I miss SCV's Aussies and feathers, especially their green ones for the age-outs (?).

    Yeah, there were times during the show when I thought "Would it have killed them to wear the classic unis and get a little more color out there?"  :)

  4. On 7/30/2018 at 12:02 AM, Southern Knights said:

    Nothing on Southern Knights?

    Apologies--I definitely should have given a shout out to the hometown corps!  Really couldn't get a feel for the visuals from my vantage point, I really enjoyed the sounds of "Knightmares". The mom tucking her daughter in at the beginning was a great image to set the mood for the entire show.

     

    • Thanks 2
  5. 12 hours ago, Dcbae!23 said:

    I have such a hard time believing this corps is sitting in 12th right now. No way is that a 12th place show, no way is that 12th place talent, no way is the design that 'bad'. It's a beautiful show and they perform it beautifully. Wow

    At the Birmingham show, I was stunned by the quality of the shows from top to bottom.  PR has much better than 12th place talent; the show design is holding them back.

    Of course, they went on right after Mandarins, which really wasn't fair.  The Mandarins' talent is not on par with PR, but they have a brilliantly designed show and they are getting everything they can out of it.

    • Like 6
×
×
  • Create New...