Here's some more pennies to throw on the pile, though I saw less of the show than Clint. Stupid equipment loading!
Seattle Cascades - well I was just coming in as they were going on and didn't have my head into really watching yet - but overall I was impressed by the show, and really impressed with how much they've been building up the last coule of years. Good strong horn sound!
Madison - I feel the show lacks the oomph! that has made the show enjoyable to watch in the past. I think the best part was the march onto the field. Bottom line - the show needs some cleaning, or else maybe as Clint said their heads weren't into it. I was disappointed to see such sloppy and frantic looking drill from the Scouts. A lot of missed tosses in the guard, and it seems the horn line isn't as strong sounding as I remember from past years. Maybe my ears are going!
SCV - one of my favorites to listen to, but it's starting to sound like the same old thing. They had a banner year in 1999, and since then it has seemed like they're trying to copy that feeling every year - modern music, beautiful ballad, fast difficult drill with lots of big diagonal lines. Again. As several people also mentioned, the box thing in the guard needs to go. There's one point where the boxes come together to form an even bigger box, which actually looked pretty cool from up top in Hayward but loses effect from ground level. Otherwise, I'm sorry but I just don't like it. Still, the show has great potential, but I'm yearning for something different from SCV.
BD - wasn't sure what to expect when reading the literature selections - but this show is growing on me. It's certainly a far cry from what they've been doing the last few years. It's, well, fun and happy. I think the ragtime opening with soloist was great - and maybe it was just because I wasn't expecting something so light and fun from BD. I find the drill to be somewhat more interesting than it has been - a wee bit not as clean as I have come to expect from BD, but I'm sure that will change. Still, I think it was the best executed show of the night.