Jump to content

ranintothedoor

Members
  • Posts

    756
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by ranintothedoor

  1. On 1/27/2020 at 7:20 PM, mingusmonk said:

    Worth noting that they are in the Community College division. 2 year schools. For one reason or a another each were not accepted at 4 year university cheer programs. Or at least, one that was a match for them.

     

     

    or could not afford a 4 year university... 

    Also, some of those kids chose to go to there for many years (3-4) because of the cheer squad.  

  2. Gotta say, I was not interested.  My wife started watching it, and I walked into the room...

    The parallels with our activity are stunning... especially that young lady whose ribs were trashed.  Crying and huddled over after every rep, and then getting up and doing it again because you just... have to... for yourself, and for the group.  

    I cried for some of the kids they spotlit (spotlighted?) and I wish I'd felt that during Clash of the Corps.  "Cheer!" did a phenomenal job.  

    • Like 2
  3. 2 minutes ago, cybersnyder said:

    Fun how a few weeks ago someone posts a Vandegrift HS video and we think its great, but if DCI adds woodwinds, it will suck. The lowest scoring  will be better than Vandegrift. DCI is good because they commit more than a year to producing 11-12 minutes of intense choreography.

    This is a good point, and part of the reason that I'll be staying a fan of DCI (or whatever it's called eventually) corps regardless of my preferences in instrumentation or how this vote goes.  

    • Like 1
  4. 17 hours ago, 2muchcoffeeman said:

    I get the aspiration to make the benefits available to as many young people as possible. I don't doubt the sincerity of the aim.

    But way to maximize the benefits isn't to eliminate the characteristics that distinguish the one thing from all other things. It's to make many different things.

    Summer string camps. Chamber orchestras. Youth symphonies. Jazz combos. Chorale. Fiddlin' competitions. Bluegrass camps. Piano competitions. Drum and bugle corps.

    I've said it before: When you put all the ingredients in the kitchen into a single pot, every item on the menu tastes the same. The way to expand the "life-enriching benefits" to more young people is to put more items on the menu, not use a bigger pot.

     

     

    This was my exact reasoning for keeping the Scouts (not just Madison, but the entire BSA) boys-only.  Have cool things for everyone... don't make everyone fit into one cool thing.  

    I'm fine if you want to discuss the pros and cons for WW in Drum Corps... but this is a terrible reason.

  5. 27 minutes ago, JimF-LowBari said:

    200 members and I keep hearing my college MB director/drill designer who kept band at 150 max. “Too many people gets in the way of my drill”.

    And we didn’t even have props to get in the way of the drill

    Yup.  Tried my hand writing for a 500 person band for 'fun' once... 3 sets and 3 hours later, decided to retire early from my glorious career writing for that size ensemble.  

    That said, huge respect for those drill writers who can and do.  

  6. I guess I'm not sure what the membership structure system would look like... so far the discussion has been compared to the Major/Minor leagues of Baseball... 

    Is DCI asking that WC groups create a required feeder program of their choice? Like, each parent organization start up a SoundSport/DLBattle/WGI ensemble/OC corps of their choice to demonstrate that they have a more solid year-to-year funding source? 

     

  7. 2 hours ago, FlamMan said:

    I mean how many kids are you really going to recruit from Japan to justify the cost of the trip? 

    This is straying too far off topic, buuuuttt.....

    Lots of talent in a totally untapped market for DCI corps, imo.  Maybe some of these Scouts can be Scouts, yaknowwudumsayin? 😄

    • Like 1
  8. 14 hours ago, chaddyt said:

    From a competitive standpoint, I think we'll have to wait and see.  Design is name of the game now, and that is something many of these folks excelled in... back in the 90s.  And while I would love to see a return to that type of drum corps, 9th place groups don't get to dictate the course of the activity.  They're going to need to do more than just zag to get back into medal contention.

    I know you're talking about competition here, but dictating the course of the activity probably shouldn't be a goal for this year (imo).  Recently, my students have been gaga over Madison, Seattle Cascades, Phantom... all of whom presented very traditional shows this year.  9th place with a fantastic show is better for recruiting (from what I've seen on the ground) than a corps medaling with a dense art-piece.  

  9. On 9/3/2019 at 12:10 AM, DCIKnowItAll said:

    The fact is they can’t design a show and they can’t attract the talent.  These changes don’t solve their real issues.

     

    My best student ran up to me yesterday and said, "DID YOU SEE THE NEWS?!? I'm doing Cadets and that's it."  He had been considering Crown and Jersey Surf.

    Bocook, Sacktig, and Aungst have a bigger following than you might give them credit for... 🙂 

    • Like 6
    • Thanks 2
  10. 5 minutes ago, MikeD said:

    In Canary Wharf there are a bunch of good places to eat. Wahahca is a Mexican place with decent food, and the Japanese place next to it is also great. Downtown a decent Japanese place called Wagamama is also good. Both have multiple locations. In downtown Greenwich, Bill's has very good food, and Greenwich Market has a bunch of food stands that are also excellent. All three restaurants will also permit you to continue to drink your sorrows away! Visit the bar at the top of the Shard for great views.

    Well, now I need to go to London.  

    ...when band's over... 

     

     

     

    ... poop.

    • Like 1
  11. 5 hours ago, Tony L. said:

    I see two paths forward based on prior examples:  that of Vanguard and Cavaliers when they slipped a bit in the rankings and that of Madison Scouts.  Please just don't chose the path of perpetual changes.  Chaos is never the answer!    

    This.  

    I also think of Blue Knights in this situation.  Every stinkin' year, they get me teared up.  They've developed an aesthetic and that leg kick thing... whatever their uniform, I can always tell it's them.  

    Even if Cadets stay in 9th perpetually from now on, I'm hoping for a strong 'Cadets' identity that is consistent year to year.  

    • Thanks 1
×
×
  • Create New...