I've always been a DCP lurker, but I feel a need to respond to this thread.
I've never gotten to participate in retreat; 2005 was my rookie very in DCI. That said, I don't have anything to compare my experience this past summer against. Personally, not having retreat had some serious pros and cons, and I feel it had more cons.
Pros:
- Being able to watch other corps shows while not in uniform
My corps wasn't one of those that performed later it shows, so not doing retreat actually played to our benefit in that sense. While I was a corps member, I was a fan at heart to even dive into this activity. I loved getting to see the Bluecoats and Cadets nearly eight times throughout tour from the stands or on the side. I saw how the shows progressed and evolved into their final products.
- Meeting people from the corps we played AoC with
I enjoyed talking to members of Colts and Crossmen. I also made friends with two Memphis Sound lead mellos one night because they were going to play AoC with Cadets that night. They didn't know the music (which was a recurring theme in all corps), so I just happened to have my music in my purse I was carrying. I let them see the music before they went out to play it. I still talk to one of those mello players :) The other two corps we played AoC with were Cadets and BAC...I didn't expect any "gobbling" from them.
Cons:
- Leaving shows early!
I detested it. I didn't like it at all because I have friends in other drum corps. I recall spending maybe a minute with a friend in another drum corps before being herded back onto the buses. Those friends are the ones that helped me make it through the summer. There's more personal feeling to put behind this con too, but it's a bit more selfish if anything. I did not like leaving San Antonio and Indianapolis before the night show. I would've appreciated getting to see the top 12 of the regionals because you could see what other corps are doing.
- Staying late if you did play AoC and/or do encore
If I played AoC, sure I'd get to stay at the show until later, but my friends in the other corps had already left by then. Basically it was either I leave the show before them, or they leave the show before me. It would've been much nicer if all corps left at once.
In conclusion, I'd appreciate not having retreat a whole lot more if I didn't have to leave a lot of shows early. It was that fact alone that killed me inside because my friends in other corps mean a lot to me. Hopefully this summer will be more bearable because of the corps I'm marching with. I'm sure I will grow to appreciate DCI's decision then :)