Jump to content

Chief Guns

Members
  • Posts

    5,574
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    116

Posts posted by Chief Guns

  1. Just now, JohnDF said:

    Saturday is going to be a happy/sad day for Chief... Hope your boy enjoys his last performance and the crowd is super pumped for the whole corps.

    Yea it's gonna be bittersweet. My wife packed the tissues lol. 

    However, his drum corps performances will be coming to an end, but he will probably end up on a corps staff next summer. He wants to be a high school band director and a corps director. 

    We won't be shocked if he ends up on staff at some OC corps next summer and beyond lol.  

    • Like 5
  2. 7 hours ago, David Hill said:

    Count me in as a Mandarins convert this year. I don't much care that competitively it is on an island, because as a concept and an entertainment it falls just right into my pleasure esthetic.

    Welcome aboard! Always room aboard the Mandarins bandwagon!

    • Like 5
  3. 13 minutes ago, NakedEye said:

    This leads to something I've been thinking about with some seeming to suggest that BD is ONLY responsible for their own successes or less successes. But they don't operate in a vacuum. Happenstance also played a part in the incredible record of the past few decades. Had Crown not had a lousy Finals run in 2015, that outcome could have been different. Had Bluecoats better nailed their ending in 2019, that could have gone the other way. On the flip side, if Phantom had not set the crowd on fire in '08, BD might have grabbed that one. 

    Even in dominant, and deservedly so, years like '23, SCV was not around to pick at the flesh of percussion (at a minimum) subcaption numbers. In '22, based on their consistent excellence and member welfare reputation, they were simply the best target destination for highly talented (and near ageout) kids squeamish from two years of pandemic. 

    BD's consistent staffing, strong design vision, and first class organization has pretty much always prepared them to win. This year is no different, even if the record on paper looks that way. They just happened to produce a high-level show that was a bit dour and cerebral in a year where three others went really bold, dynamic, and brought the fire. Their response next year should be pretty interesting.

    I agree with everything you said except for one small part........

    "if Phantom had not set the crowd on fire in '08, BD might have grabbed that one."

    I don't think it had anything to do with the crowd. It had more to do with BDs drums picking the worst time to have a bad run by their standards, and getting knocked down to 5th finals night, which cracked the door for Phantom to walk thru. 

    Phantom won fair and square, but if BDs drums took care of business, there is no door for Phantom to walk thru, regardless of what the crowd thought. 

     

    • Like 3
  4. 1 minute ago, bluecoats88 said:

    I knew I missed someone, Mandarins would be in the Thoroughly enjoyed category.  Didn't mean to slight them in the least 

    Oh it's all love bro! We were just messing with ya. 

    Glad you had a great time at Allentown. My son said the crowd was lit and the corps fed off it. 

    • Like 1
  5. 4 minutes ago, KVG_DC said:

    Not sure.  Spartans making their last year in Open this year of course.  Battalion has been ROARING up in quality and size.  Gold has gotten super consistent there too.   I'm not connected enough to any of them to know if they're planning to make the jump anytime soon.  

    Next year should be a "BDB goes to Indy" year again so they will be the favorites.  Although Spartans beat them last year on a "BDB goes to Indy" year so beating BDB in August isn't impossible for Open Class.  If Gold stays consistent and comes out with a sparkling design and Battalion continues their rise with these brilliant shows of the past two years, Open Class could be fun to track at the top next year. 

    BDB wouldn't have made top 12, but I'll say this, after seeing them live in SoCal last month, I am sure quite a few WC corps were doing this after realizing BDB wasn't coming to Indy...................

    whew-goldblum.gif

    • Like 1
    • Haha 1
  6. 31 minutes ago, bluecoats88 said:

    It's a solid year,  I found in Allentown as opposed to other years I may have only once gotten a little zoned out during maybe 1 or 2 shows this year and usually I find there are many more that just don't click for me.

    Definately loved Bluecoats, SCV, Phantom, Troopers, and Cascades

    Thoroughly enjoyed BD, Colts, Blue Knights, Spirit, Crossmen (Such a simple theme done so well), Genesis,  and Spartans

    Not sold, but they were good Boston, Crown, Cavaliers, Blue Stars, PC, Music City, Madison, and Academy

     

    You got every corps, except for one. 

    Mandarins be like...................

    source.gif

    • Haha 3
  7. 2 minutes ago, brassboy said:

    I know, I know: different shows, no top tier corps in Edinboro. But Mandarins score tonight is less than 1 point behind Crown and Phantom. From an optics standpoint, that sure makes things look a lot more fun.

    Gap was 1.4 and 1.6 to PR and Crown in Allentown. Mandarins aren't dead just yet. 

    • Like 4
×
×
  • Create New...