brassboy
Members-
Posts
2,281 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by brassboy
-
The published recaps list Webb as MA for Saturday night (like he was for Friday night). However, at the start of Saturday night’s show the announcer announced a different judge on MA. However, it’s also very possible that they didn’t give the announcer an updated judges list on Saturday night (like how they didn’t give him an updated schedule on Friday night and he almost went to internission).
-
Finals... Colts, Troopers or both.
brassboy replied to bandman28's topic in DCI World Class Corps Discussions
That was my point. They had two fewer weeks on tour than usual this year. They would have had two more weeks of progress by the time COVID hit. -
Finals... Colts, Troopers or both.
brassboy replied to bandman28's topic in DCI World Class Corps Discussions
It’s a shame Troopers didn’t have their first competition until July 8. They’re usually on the road opening weekend. If they had started a week or two earlier, I think talk of them being in finals could have been a lot more like “11th or 12th?” vs. “will they?” -
You keep pointing to 2019 and Crown/SCV. In Allentown, Crown's score was less than 0.1 ahead of SCV's from the previous night. At Finals, SCV finished less than 0.1 ahead of Crown. It is entirely conceivable that Crown on Saturday was ever-so-slightly better than SCV was one night prior. You've really picked this hill to die on and I don't know why. No one is disagreeing that the logistics of treating it as one show are shaky, but the fact of the matter is that the INTENT is that both nights are treated as a single show. That's all everyone is saying.
-
Except Allentown is the exception. Same panel both nights and they treat it as one large show over two days, including using Friday's numbers for reference. The comparison is shakier because (1) one set of corps technically had an additional day of rehearsal before competing, and (2) the judges are only human but do their best to remember performances from the previous night.
-
I think a lot of people overlook also the care that was taken in the writing for voice and brass here. This isn’t merely the brass playing accompaniment to a vocalist—both the brass and vocalist carry melody that trade-off or complement each other simultaneously.
-
2007 Division I shows (and Denver/Boise/Ogden were shortly before the august shows): 6/16 Pleasant Hill, CA 6/17 Stockton, CA 6/20 Bakersfield, CA 6/22 Riverside, CA 6/23 Walnut, CA 6/24 Glendale, AZ 8/2 Albuquerque, NM 8/2 Hillsboro, OR 8/4 Tempe, AZ 8/4 Stanford, CA 8/5 San Diego, CA 8/5 Clovis, CA 8/7 - 8/12 DCI Championships