How would you have judged entertainment in 2010

[glory]

A proposed new rule would institute judging of "entertainment" qualities. I'm inviting you to apply that rule retroactively to the 2010 program. I'm curious how the outspoken DCP crowd would apply this standard. Have fun.

I've used above/below average to keep this simple.

HH

[Tom Brace]

stupid poll...it need to allow for "no votes" for the second question.

[glory]

stupid poll...it need to allow for "no votes" for the second question.

You can assign the above/below ratings to as many or as few as you like (and no rating if you prefer that).

Don't blame the poll. Blame the pollster. Stupid as charged!

HH

[bluecoats88]

I figured if I thought the show was average from an entertainment standing then it wouldn't get an above or below vote.

[Tom Brace]

You can assign the above/below ratings to as many or as few as you like (and no rating if you prefer that).

Don't blame the poll. Blame the pollster. Stupid as charged!

HH

I left all choices blank on the second question and received an error.

[bluecoats88]

We actually did a ranking after last season an asked people to renk the top 12 by entertainment.

I gave 1 points for a 1st on down to 12 points for a 12th. (The Lower the score the better)

Here is the results from that survey.

Entertainment Rankings

1.) Madison Scouts 339

2.) Cavaliers 362

3.) Bluecoats 460

4.) Carolina Crown 461

5.) Phantom Regiment 476

6.) Cadets 517

7.) Blue Stars 607

8.) Blue Knights 677

9.) Santa Clara Vanguard 727

10.) Blue Devils 728

11.) Boston Crusaders 729

12.) Glassmen 1004

[Tom Brace]

We actually did a ranking after last season an asked people to renk the top 12 by entertainment.

I gave 1 points for a 1st on down to 12 points for a 12th. (The Lower the score the better)

Here is the results from that survey.

Entertainment Rankings

1.) Madison Scouts 339

2.) Cavaliers 362

3.) Bluecoats 460

4.) Carolina Crown 461

5.) Phantom Regiment 476

6.) Cadets 517

7.) Blue Stars 607

8.) Blue Knights 677

9.) Santa Clara Vanguard 727

10.) Blue Devils 728

11.) Boston Crusaders 729

12.) Glassmen 1004

We meaning DCP participants? Can't be accurate...so many here claim they never go to DCI shows anymore.

[glory]

I left all choices blank on the second question and received an error.

Don't blame the pollster, blame the system. Don't take no shizzle from the man!

HH

[glory]

So with 40 ballots cast so far (love round numbers), here’s where we would have given advantage/disadvantage had we been judging the 2010 shows using the entertainment rule.

Getting a boost: Cavies, Scouts, Phantom

Getting a haircut: Devils, SCV, Glassmen

HH

Edited January 14, 2011 by glory

[BRASSO]

We meaning DCP participants? Can't be accurate...so many here claim they never go to DCI shows anymore.

It's like voting in America.. there's no requirement that you know the difference between a filibuster and a Ghostbuster, or whether one could find Washington,D.C. on a US map. Even dummies who never see or know a thing get to vote. This DCP poll included.

Edited January 14, 2011 by BRASSO