I go to a DCI show to be entertained, I dont think of DCI as a sporting event. The desire to win, and the general thrill of competition drives some corps and alot of the fans, but it really doesnt bother me. I think that too many people are bashing a program because it isnt exactly what they want, instead of just accepting it as what it is. If a new idea or innovation upset me that much, then I guess I would just go get some popcorn, instead of trying to limit what a growing activity can and cannot do.
This thread was made because people feel unhappy about the placement that SCV and Xmen are getting right? Since when has that mattered to a real fan? I had the privelage of watching both corps perform in Indy this past saturday and I was impressed with their program and I appreciated it for what it was.
I remember earlier someone saying that there isnt enough emphasis on music, I agree. But I wouldnt go after judges throats, but instead the brass staff of said corps. I dont want people going for my throat, but there are a few shows in recent years that didnt cross my ears as musical, but instead just impressive.
Overall I wish the best for Xmen and SCV for the rest of the season, I just hope that the fans see how little scoring and placement matter. Hopefully a few alumni can back me on saying that the experience greatly outweighs the outcome on finals night.