I think its pretty unfair to attack any corps member in this manner, she works just as hard as anyone in the corps and does not deserve, what I believe to be such a unfair personal attack. Members are asked to perform what is given to them, how would you like to be this members parent checking out feedback on the site on how said child is doing this summer and see this.
Critique the design not the member.
Personally, I think it works and am excited to see the end product, layers and new colors are a good thing, well unless you are still struggling with that color T.V idea.
Anthony