"I'm thinking about Crown defeating Phantom in guard. I have no insight as to why the current Crown guard designer left PR several years ago, but I'm sure the win in San Antonio was sweet, especially if it keeps up..."
"I'm thinking about Crown defeating Phantom in guard." - This is what the OP is referring to.
"but I'm sure the win in San Antonio was sweet, especially if it keeps up..." - This is also referring to the "victory" of placing higher in that single caption.
Win meaning first place is your own opinion. OP said they "won" in the guard caption. Please learn how to comprehend the English language if you are going to get into an argument.
It's as simple as that. I'm walking away from this pointless argument now.