Jared-good post! Many other fine viewpoints weighing the merits of show design, staff, performer talent base, expectations, identity et.al.
I, too have devoted numerous hours observing rehearsals, interaction of staff with performers and monitoring the corps' rise in finals.
I respectfully disagree with the previous poster's description that the identity/impression/moniker of the corps is competent-I simply must give more credit, not only to this corps, but all. I think excellence fits better.
So, my vote. Yes, I know competitive arenas beg for predictions [da bears WILL win the division again]. But as much as it seems to be skirting the topic, I am uncomfortable in the arts attempting to predict outcomes.
IOW-I can easily accept if "MY" corps [whomever that might be] places anywhere from year to year as long as I feel that the product IS excellence, and most importantly the approach of the organization is educationally and emotionally well-grounded.
Because the Bluecoats as an organization, imho have consistently embraced this ethic their presence is now among the highest come finals. I think they have remained true and genuine and are reaping benefits.
Every year in DCI there are several "Gold" level finales. Thank goodness for that.