Jump to content

Highest scoring __ Place Shows of All Time?


Recommended Posts

I've got a spreadsheet for the top 12 with all this info including smallest and largest spreads from 1st -2nd, 1st-3rd, etc on down to 1st-12th. for instance the bluecoats have the highest ever 7th place score and that year was also the smallest spread between 1st and 7th place at only 3.95 points.

Smallest spreads

1st-2nd 0 points (1996, 1999, & 2000 since there was a tie for first there was no second place)

1st-3rd 0.35 points (1978 Blue Devils)

1st-4th 0.80 points (1980 Spirit of Atlanta)

1st-5th 2.00 points (1988 Cavaliers)

1st-6th 3.20 points (1981 Bridgemen)

1st-7th 3.95 points (2007 Bluecoats)

1st-8th 6.00 points (1992 Phantom Regiment)

1st-9th 7.50 points (1992 Blue Knights)

1st-10th 8.00 points (1988 Suncoast Sound)

1st-11th 10.40 points (1988 Bluecoats)

1st-12th 12.00 points (1988 Sky Ryders)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For 13th to 25th highest Scoring corps

I used the last performance scores for corps in this group.

13th - 86.40 1988 Dutch boy

14th - 85.60 1988 Crossmen

15th - 85.20 1988 Freelancers

16th - 83.00 1990 Magic of Orlando

17th - 81.15 1977 Boston Crusaders

18th - 80.60 1977 North Star

19th - 80.15 2003 Capital Regiment

20th - 78.80 1977 Troopers

21st - 78.55 1977 Royal Crusaders

22nd - 78.50 1977 Argonauts

23rd - 76.35 1977 Spirit of Atlanta

24th - 74.35 1977 Wausau Story

25th - 74.25 1977 Velvet Knights

According to my records in 1977 when Bridgemen were disqualified after performing in finals the final placements showed no 13th place corpsthis is why all of the 1977 corps are showing up. If I shift all corps up one spot in 1977, then the high score results change to the following.

13th - 86.40 1988 Dutch boy

14th - 85.60 1988 Crossmen

15th - 85.20 1988 Freelancers

16th - 83.00 1990 Magic of Orlando

17th - 81.05 2011 Crossmen

18th - 80.35 2010 Pacific Crest

19th - 80.15 2003 Capital Regiment

20th - 78.75 2003 Kiwanis Kavaliers

21st - 78.50 1977 Argonauts

22nd - 76.35 1977 Spirit of Atlanta

23rd - 74.925 2004 Troopers

24th - 74.25 1977 Velvet Knights

25th - 73.10 1977 Colts

Link to comment
Share on other sites

According to my records in 1977 when Bridgemen were disqualified after performing in Finals, the final placements showed no 13th place corps--this is why all of the 1977 corps are showing up. If I shift all corps up one spot in 1977, then the high score results change to the following.

That's fascinating. So if the Bridgemen had not ultimately been disqualified, the Garfield Cadets would be a 13th-place Finalist (having tied with Kilties for 12th in Prelims). And those 1977 corps ranked 14th-25th in Prelims really earned those historically high scores, relative to their rank. It's only by disqualifying the Bridgemen that these other groups seem less impressive!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just for fun, I tried to determine which corps achieved the most impressive first-place, second-place, third-place, etc. position in a historical context, by comparing each score to the average of Finals (for the top 12) or Prelims/Semifinals scores (for the top 17) in that year.

For instance, to consider first-place scores: the average Finals score in 2011 was 92.213; the Cadets scored 98.350, or 6.66% above the average. The average Finals score in 2010 was 92.696; the Blue Devils scored 98.900, or 6.69% above the average. The average Finals score in 2009 was 92.388; the Blue Devils scored 99.050, or 7.21% above the average. Of those three, the 1999 Blue Devils seemed to have most outscored their field.

However, the results are most perplexing. I was looking for the overachievers, but I'm not sure what I found:

1st - 1975 Madison Scouts

2nd - 1983 Blue Devils

3rd - 1983 Santa Clara Vanguard

4th - 1983 Phantom Regiment

5th - 1980 Phantom Regiment

6th - 1980 Madison Scouts

7th - 1980 Santa Clara Vanguard

8th - 1992 Phantom Regiment

9th - 1992 Blue Knights

10th - 1979 Blue Stars

11th - 1977 Crossmen

12th - 2005 Spirit

13th - 2007 Academy

14th - 2007 Blue Stars

15th - 2007 Madison Scouts

16th - 2007 Crossmen

17th - 2007 Pacific Crest

I have no idea why the years would clump together in that way!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As a side note, the highest 5th place score was actually SCV's semis performance in 2009, with a score of 95.9. It looks like we are just going by final scores, but I imagine there could be few more of those out there.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

...

According to my records in 1977 when Bridgemen were disqualified after performing in finals the final placements showed no 13th place corps this is why all of the 1977 corps are showing up. If I shift all corps up one spot in 1977, then the high score results change to the following.

...

The reason no 13th place score shows up is because Garfield Cadets and Kilties both tied for 12th at the 1977 DCI World Championship Prelims. Considering that, I'd personally stick with your first list (without the adjustment).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also, on the contrary, do you think we could get a list of the LOWEST placing scores of each placement? It would be interesting to compare them with the highest placing scores from each placement to see if a show would have won had it been performed a different year.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here is a list through 17th place. It's all 1972, 1973, and oddly enough, 1980:

1st - 88.100 - 1972 Kingsmen

2nd - 86.150 - 1973 Troopers

3rd - 85.500 - 1973 Blue Stars

4th - 83.550 - 1973 Madison Scouts

5th - 82.900 - 1972 Argonne Rebels

6th - 81.950 - 1972 Troopers

7th - 79.400 - 1973 27th Lancers

8th - 79.300 - 1973 Muchachos

9th - 77.400 - 1980 Cavaliers

10th - 75.750 - 1973 Black Knights

11th - 73.150 - 1973 Argonne Rebels

12th - 72.250 - 1973 Commodores

13th - 75.550 - 1973 DeLaSalle Oaklands

14th - 74.700 - 1973 Phantom Regiment

15th - 71.950 - 1980 Seattle Imperials

16th - 71.150 - 1980 Long Island Kingsmen

17th - 69.700 - 1980 Sky Ryders

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...