I've drifted in and out of discussion forums and newsgroups for years, and have seen this debate a million times. I can assure you it's the same in every country that has drum corps or band season, however small. What's constant is that the "old" people always seem to have an interest in drum corps in the years before, during and after they were involved, whereas the "young" people only seem to be interested in the activity during the present and recent past. I can't tell you why this is, but it's a theme which runs through all discussion groups. There seems to be a line at about 1995 which divides the 2 groups.
I sometimes wonder whether it's the "winning is everything" society we now live in, where our own competition is all that's important, and everything else is irrelevant.
Anyway, my vote, for what it's worth is to keep it separate. I've spent many happy hours in the past few days browsing through here, and I'd hate to have to wade through a mass of almost unreadable drivel in order to pick out the good stuff. The butchery of the English language is something I don't want to get started on.
Disclaimer: I know there are exceptions to all this, so don't bother.