The Visual Proficiency caption has a content subcaption ( how much demand is in the drill ) and an achievement sub caption ( ie, how well you perform the drill ). The Crusaders were 5th in both content and achievement of their drill in their performance this San Antonio Regional. Ironically, the Crusaders were 1st in Guard this show, that likewise has a content and achievement sub captions component. Unless I'm mistaken ( If I'm wrong on this, I apologize ), the 40+ member Guard is not excluded from the Visual Proficiency assessment of their performance by the VP judge, whereby just the battery in percussion and the brass only are being assessed in content and achievement. If this is true, then it is a bit perplexing how the Corps was 5th in Visual Proficiency, but 1st in Guard.
Nevertheless, I agree with you that this judge should be given the benefit of the doubt ( he's an experienced, well trained judge ), and accept the assessment, learn from it, work harder in practice in this area, and move forward with even more determination to impress the judges .