Yes – Well it would be hard to convince someone who is solidly in the 1st camp. My argument is that there is not way to be “shafted” if a director was playing the season with the points given. The only way that could happen is if they tried to predict what the final cap would be and select captions from there.
There will be directors who still choose to go that route, although it would be a gamble. OR they could just play the points give, then work out where they would go if they got 2 more, 3 more, 4 more points. Make their caption changes. Then start the process over, where will I go if I got 1 more, 2 more, 3 more points.
It’s just a more fair way of managing your corps. Everyone is in the same boat so to speak.