As a younger fan, whom didn't see these shows live, I can't really say that SCV was more "emotional" in 89 than 88, as sometimes has been said, but I can say that 88 was cleaner by my DVD, however, Madison clearly looked the better that night. But 89 imo should have been given to Phantom Regiment. That show is jaw dropping. I show it to new marchers and they are amazed everytime.