weedyweidenthal

Members
  • Content Count

    215
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

86 Excellent

About weedyweidenthal

  • Rank
    DCP Veteran

Profile Information

  • Your Drum Corps Experience
    Spirit from JSU 2007; Madison Scouts 2008; Madison Scouts 2009
  • Your Favorite Corps
    Madison Scouts
  • Your Favorite All Time Corps Performance (Any)
    1999 Madison Scouts
  • Your Favorite Drum Corps Season
    2011
  • Gender
    Male

Contact Methods

  • Website URL
    http://
  • ICQ
    0

Recent Profile Visitors

415 profile views
  1. weedyweidenthal

    2019 Madison Scouts!

    I would give up a lot to be able to march under Dann’s and Chris’s direction just one more time. Your criticism is misguided and aimed at the wrong people.
  2. weedyweidenthal

    Past 10 Seasons

    I picked 2011 just because of how much fun I had feeling the reaction to "Empire State of Mind" from the field. I honestly don't remember a single other show from that year though.
  3. So you’ll commit credit card fraud (and openly admit it) after you purchased something with agreed upon terms? Interesting strategy
  4. weedyweidenthal

    2019 Madison Scouts!

    Using the span of time since an all male corps has been a champion and using that as an argument in favor of going coed is a really poor strategy. In the timespan since the last all male championship, one corps has won the title 7 times. 16 of the 22 coed corps also haven’t won a championship. Several of those 16 haven’t even been in finals (or for at least one now suspended corps, semifinals) in that same time frame. Both all male corps have gone through struggles with things off the field which has hurt both of their competitive success (although, for the Cavs it’s been to a far lesser extent).
  5. weedyweidenthal

    2019 Madison Scouts!

    I can only speak about the years that I marched... 2008-2011. From what I understood when I was a rookie, the design team from 2008 had originally agreed to a three year commitment. 2009 was clearly a step backwards in design. We rarely saw the design team in 2009 and we were kind of left scrambling to fix the issues and it fell mostly to the caption heads to do work that I would consider design team obligations. They were replaced in 2010. I spoke with Jim Mason and Donnie Vandoren during the winter camps and I was told their intent was to be there for 5 years and get the corps back on the right track. Jim, being an alumnus, was doing it because of his passion for the corps and Donnie was there for his passion for the activity. My impression was that Donnie wanted to help as many corps as possible and that his belief was that 5 years was enough time to build a solid foundation and that he would then go on to another corps in need. After 2014 they had completed their 5 years and ready to move on. I think there was a lot of excitement for the design team that came in and the 2015 show seemed to show that they had accomplished their goal of bringing the Scouts back. I don't know what happened with the designs of the last 3 years. I think 2016 was a good concept with poor execution of the musical book. The last 2 years have been a bit weird and obviously not a lot of people have been pleased, so now they've been replaced again. I think many people that marched during the Mason years would have loved to see that era continue, but that wasn't the plan of those individuals. I am intrigued by the design team changes. The statements from Jim Elvord seem exciting, I just hope that the team follows through with the execution of the plans they've stated.
  6. weedyweidenthal

    2019 Madison Scouts!

    Seems pretty obvious that the design of the shows that haven't made finals was the problem... The design team is gone and replaced. In 2008, a lot of us thought we were on the right track with the design team, and then they came out with Relampago. In 2010 we got the Mason Entertainment Group and everything was trending in the right direction. Jim had made it clear to a lot of people from the beginning that he was on board for 5 years. Now we've had 3 years of design issues. It's been shown over the last ten years that this leadership team is actually pretty #### good, but the on field product needs better designs. In fact, Dann Peterson was awarded Director of the Year in 2010 and Chris Komnick got the award in 2012.
  7. weedyweidenthal

    2019 Madison Scouts!

    I’d be interested to learn why that is... To be honest I’m not entirely sure that’s the case either. I thought 2005 Scouts was great writing. I think when he gets to arrange a full tune he does a great job, but the choppiness of a lot of the shows he has been asked to write for doesn’t seem to suit him (or any arranger for that matter) well. I missed him by a year at Spirit, and was 2 years after him as well as 3 years before him at Madison. It would have been great to perform a book he wrote (not that I can really complain... Jim Prime and Robert W. Smith were awesome to learn from).
  8. weedyweidenthal

    2019 Madison Scouts!

    Count me as one of the many people that loves Scott's arrangements from his first stint with the Scouts. That said, I don't think he did anything that distinctive in his more recent stint. Maybe he needed more creative control, or maybe he just needed an old school show design to bring the sound back, but to me this is more of a sentimental loss than anything. Really #### poor attempt at trolling from a guy who has less than 90 posts over the last 16 years, almost all of which have been about Madison, and almost all of which have had some type of negative implication.
  9. weedyweidenthal

    Pioneer Member Rant

    Sounds like a few legitimate major complaints and then a lot of #####ing... That said, it's surprising that parents still let their high school aged children march with Pioneer. It's not like these complaints are new. Roman has had so many allegations made about him acting this way in the last decade, there were sexual harassment allegations against the corps, the corps has been struggling financially ever since I marched starting back in 2007 so they can barely field a corps... I might be blasted for this, but it could be time to pack it up.
  10. weedyweidenthal

    Madison Scouts 2018

    HAHAHAHA! I nearly died laughing when I read this. Of all the silly things to bring up. Calling alums and age outs "Old Balls" has been going on by members since at least the 90's. It is a joke. It is said in fun. Any one of the alums that walked into a gym on tour was always greeted with "Old balls in the gym!!!" It was an immediate thing upon aging out. The day after finals when everyone was clearing up, any age out that walked in was greeted that way. The truth is, even if you have issues with the leadership, we do need to do more if we want the corps to thrive. No reason they shouldn't be saying that. In fact, I hope they say it more and appeal to more alums to give more. If you have issues with the staff/admin, why not send them messages letting them know what you're unhappy with. Do so thoughtfully and respectfully rather than on a whim or aggressively, and they will meet you half way. I know this from personal experience as I've let them hear my thoughts from time to time.
  11. weedyweidenthal

    Madison Scouts 2018

    I suppose that’s an opinion, but it is a highly misguided opinion. There’s no doubt, the corps is struggling. It doesn’t look good. However, Dann and Chris have had a hugely positive impact on my (and hundreds of other young men’s) lives. That in itself is a tremendous accolade. Even if there is a call to remove the current leadership and go in a new direction, their contributions should not go unappreciated. That said though, the corps just released a plan for the future success of the corps during his last offseason. From what I’ve seen and what I understand from talking with people in the know, it looks good. For those of us that aren’t attending meetings and are here complaining on forums rather than getting involved and contributing, we might not know all the information necessary to call this a failure and abort so early into their current plans. I’m not particularly happy with the corps’ immediate success either, but to call for firing without being active in the corps is a big mistake as well.
  12. weedyweidenthal

    Madison Scouts 2018

    Hey bro, a few guys were asking how to get in contact with you a few days ago on the alumni FB page. I hope you're doing well.
  13. weedyweidenthal

    Murder & Drum Corps--Bizarre Story

    Yes. A lady attended a drum corps show... when has that ever been worth discussing? In addition to that, criminal activity related to drum corps has been something largely ignored and there is a much more interesting topic that would be of interest to many people in the historical corps discussion that has been hushed up (which I'm guessing you are aware of) that involves a drum major of the Cadets and the eventual corps director of the Muchachos, but that topic normally gets shut up pretty quickly. Firstly, that would actually be really humorous for me, but it would be incredibly easy as I have a fairly large digital footprint dating back to at least 2004 and I've always used the same screen name, which is the name I go by in real life as well. Secondly, this article brings nothing of value to the forum.
  14. weedyweidenthal

    Murder & Drum Corps--Bizarre Story

    This should be deleted... Not related to the activity
  15. weedyweidenthal

    Madison Scouts 2017

    That's an "interesting" perspective. The way I saw it was Brad was one of the best, most dedicated instructors the corps could have asked for for 5 years when he was given the opportunity to pursue his dream of being an arranger for a world class corps. Most of us that had the opportunity to learn from him were sad to see him go but happy for him. I am very grateful to have had the chance to learn from him...