Seen a run through from everyone in last year’s top 12 with the exception of Colts so far.
1. Bluecoats - what a drumline. Love the lean into weirdness with still being accessible. Great ballad.
2. Blue Devils - honestly, I think they’ll win, BUT, I love this show. Why is this a problem? They never seem to win when I love what they’re doing. 92, 06, 11, etc. etc.
3. Carolina Crown - strongest design since 2016. Would not be shocked if Boston tops them. Drum writing is better this year - digging it.
4. Boston - killer guard. Don’t love the horn book or drum ramming. But the kids’ talent is undeniable.
5. Blue Stars - Unbelievable lush brass sound and a guard book that’s full of I-can’t-believe-they-just-did-that moments.
6. Phantom - love the music. Very Phantom while getting a modern upgrade. Muse is a great fit.
7. Cadets - great drumline. Visual book got a nice step up. Really enjoying what they have so far.
8. Mandarins - love seeing these guys on the rise!
9. Troopers - a step up from 2022. They’re really gunning for it. Lots more demand in the visual program in terms of individual responsibilities this time around.
10. Cavaliers - tasty percussion writing. Very underwhelmed with what they’re doing considering the greatness of the source material. Still, a fun package with Easter eggs everywhere. Enjoyed it on first viewing quite a bit, just don’t see a high competitive ceiling
11. Colts - haven’t seen it. Always love the red team. Looking forward to them this year.
12. No clue. This might be the single most interesting slot on finals night.