Matt Williams Posted July 20, 2010 Share Posted July 20, 2010 I am wondering about the comparison between the DCUK and DCA sheets,judging. Are they on the same sheets? Any help?? JC I would imagine that the DCUK (DCE) Sheets are fairly different. They are working to a new Judging system this year. If you wish to get the complete low down I'm sure that you can get info from the DCE website Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JCSeymour Posted July 20, 2010 Share Posted July 20, 2010 (edited) JC I would imagine that the DCUK (DCE) Sheets are fairly different.They are working to a new Judging system this year. If you wish to get the complete low down I'm sure that you can get info from the DCE website Thanks Matt. So the scores for Kidsgrove so far could be way low or way high or dead on,in comparison to the DCA sheets. Good luck in August Edited July 20, 2010 by JCSeymour Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TomPeashey Posted July 20, 2010 Share Posted July 20, 2010 I'm told that Bob Thomas had a lot to do with the European sheets and that he told them they were modeled more on DCA than DCI, but then you read the criteria scale and it seems to be more stringent (like DCI world class) than DCA... this would - of course - make scores LOWER. That being said... comparing scores from show to show is difficult enough and very problematic... from system to system is impossible, misleading and dangerous. Best suggestion: Catch Kidsgrove in Bridgeport or Rochester and decide for yourself. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
4181jay Posted July 20, 2010 Share Posted July 20, 2010 dont know much about the difference between DCUK and DCA judging but I did catch Kidsgrove at warrington on sunday. sweet baritone line! Show quite dirty all the way through but I'm putting it down to the wet field. Good start, good finish but seemed to get lost in the middle. Maybe it was where I was stood (just outside the 40, just popped in during work to catch a few corps. couldn't sit down in uniform and had to have an ear to the radio!) but there appeared to be a bit of apprehension in the performance. Its going to need a big cleaning job between now and DCUK/DCE finals to catch the Company. I think you'll like them over there. good old fashioned, brash, in your face Drum Corps! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camel lips Posted July 25, 2010 Share Posted July 25, 2010 **** DCA All-Age Corps - Based on Newest Score **** Open Class: 01 (01) - 89.913 (2) - Buccaneers 02 (03) - 86.613 (2) - Hurricanes 03 (02) - 86.175 (1) - Empire Statesmen 04 (06) - 85.825 (1) - Minnesota Brass 05 (04) - 85.513 (2) - Caballeros 06 (05) - 79.375 (0) - CorpsVets 07 (07) - 74.875 (7) - Renegades 08 (08) - 74.813 (4) - Bushwackers 09 (09) - 72.038 (3) - Kilties 10 (10) - 65.200 (!) - Alliance Class A: 01 (04) - 74.863 (2) - Fusion Core 02 (06) - 74.463 (1) - Carolina Gold 03 (01) - 73.800 (2) - Grenadiers 04 (NR) - 71.563 (1) - Sun Devils 05 (02) - 70.263 (6) - Govenaires 06 (03) - 68.613 (1) - White Sabers 07 (05) - 67.000 (7) - SoCal Dream 08 (07) - 67.000 (5) - Shenandoah Sound 09 (08) - 59.220 (9) - High Country Brass 10 (09) - 58.500 (8) - Cincinnati Tradition 11 (10) - 55.250 (5) - Excelsior ------- (1) = 07/24/2010 - Jamestown, NY (DCA) (2) = 07/24/2010 - Lawrence, MA (DCA) (3) = 07/18/2010 - Rockford, IL (DCI) (4) = 07/17/2010 - Lewisburg, PA (DCA) (5) = 07/17/2010 - Schenectady, NY (DCA) (6) = 07/17/2010 - Minneapolis, MN (DCI) (7) = 07/17/2010 - Paramount, CA (DCI) (8) = 07/12/2010 - Fairfield, OH (DCI) (9) = 07/10/2010 - Denver, CO (DCI) (0) = 07/10/2010 - Hornell, NY (DCA) (!) = 06/20/2010 - Ft Mill, SC (DCI) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
donincardona Posted July 25, 2010 Share Posted July 25, 2010 **** DCA All-Age Corps - Based on Newest Score ****Open Class: 01 (01) - 89.913 (2) - Buccaneers 02 (03) - 86.613 (2) - Hurricanes 03 (02) - 86.175 (1) - Empire Statesmen 04 (06) - 85.825 (1) - Minnesota Brass 05 (04) - 85.513 (2) - Caballeros 06 (05) - 79.375 (0) - CorpsVets 07 (07) - 74.875 (7) - Renegades 08 (08) - 74.813 (4) - Bushwackers 09 (09) - 72.038 (3) - Kilties 10 (10) - 65.200 (!) - Alliance Class A: 01 (04) - 74.863 (2) - Fusion Core 02 (06) - 74.463 (1) - Carolina Gold 03 (01) - 73.800 (2) - Grenadiers 04 (NR) - 71.563 (1) - Sun Devils 05 (02) - 70.263 (6) - Govenaires 06 (03) - 68.613 (1) - White Sabers 07 (05) - 67.000 (7) - SoCal Dream 08 (07) - 67.000 (5) - Shenandoah Sound 09 (08) - 59.220 (9) - High Country Brass 10 (09) - 58.500 (8) - Cincinnati Tradition 11 (10) - 55.250 (5) - Excelsior ------- (1) = 07/24/2010 - Jamestown, NY (DCA) (2) = 07/24/2010 - Lawrence, MA (DCA) (3) = 07/18/2010 - Rockford, IL (DCI) (4) = 07/17/2010 - Lewisburg, PA (DCA) (5) = 07/17/2010 - Schenectady, NY (DCA) (6) = 07/17/2010 - Minneapolis, MN (DCI) (7) = 07/17/2010 - Paramount, CA (DCI) (8) = 07/12/2010 - Fairfield, OH (DCI) (9) = 07/10/2010 - Denver, CO (DCI) (0) = 07/10/2010 - Hornell, NY (DCA) (!) = 06/20/2010 - Ft Mill, SC (DCI) so what happened to spandy. he put's the plus and minus from the last week and the score from the last week. i mean good job but where has he been ? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camel lips Posted July 26, 2010 Share Posted July 26, 2010 so what happened to spandy. he put's the plus and minus from the last week and the score from the last week. i mean good job but where has he been ? He may have a real life :) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MiniSopGuy Posted July 26, 2010 Share Posted July 26, 2010 (edited) now this is traditionaly one of my favorite threads. i hope we don't get a lot of controversy this year. good luck to all the corps. I always like watching this thread too. I see our score hanging near the top in July, when we haven't even put the entire show on the field, but then we start falling like a stone the rest of the season. It actually pushes us harder to be cleaner buy the time we are on the same field with the same judges as everyone else in Rochester. SoCal Dream has now entered into our annual stealth mode.....see you on September 4th...... Edited July 26, 2010 by MiniSopGuy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CaliforniaDCfan Posted July 26, 2010 Share Posted July 26, 2010 Man, no love for the west coast in most of the predictions! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
KeithHall Posted July 26, 2010 Share Posted July 26, 2010 No, it's not lack of love (IMO) I believe it's more like the corps that have made it to the Northeast as well as the northeast haven't seen the West coast. Sad that either the west corps couldn't come east or the east corps going west. The midwest and southern corps try to get up there at least once before championships. Sadly, we still see the South, Midwest and West corps do the bulk of the traveling. Man, no love for the west coast in most of the predictions! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.