* No question they are a visual distraction for not only audience, but for the production crew making the videos (there's a great video on youtube I think of the production room where the director curses when a judge gets in the way of a good shot). The question is, are judges a SIGNIFICANT distraction? I don't think people skip shows because judges get in the way, and I'm fairly sure people don't buy DVD's or Blu-rays specifically because judges ruin shots. So if we're being honest, they are a very minor distraction at best.
* I'm not sure eliminating field judges would eliminate any cost. There would still be a brass & percussion judge, and likely one vis judge to evaluate ensemble and one to evaluate individual/small groups. I think eliminating judges for cost-savings is a valid discussion, but not really in context here: eliminating the percussion field judges does not equal eliminating the percussion judge completely.
* judging the lot is interesting from a conceptual idea, but not really practical. Lots = time for members to not only warm-up (sometimes after a long bus ride from housing to stadium), but also a time for members to mentally get in the performance zone. If lots were officially judged, there would need to be, like, a pre-lot warm-up zone or something for members to warm-up before their adjudicated warm-up. Then you'd have judges running around to catch the groups, possibly not having a ton of time to think rationally about numbers, etc. Perhaps there are solutions to all of those, but seems like an unnecessary hassle.
* how many serious collisions are there every season? I know those are rarely "reported" publicly, so it is difficult to get a legit assessment, but I would guess very few. While there is always an inherent risk of that, there is FAR more risk of accidents happening due to membership missing a direction change, slipping on the field, or any other weird thing (like the Crown member who went down at Finals a few years ago). Perhaps field judges are not really that big of a cause of concern here
* I'm way to verbose
* bummer we had to ruin a nice, fun, goofy thread with legit argument